Local News: India 

 | 

Sign Up

 | 

Sign In

Physiotherapists are not doctors: MCI

Posted in the India Forum

Read

1,755 Comments

More India Discussions »

Comments (Page 78)

Showing posts 1,541 - 1,560 of1,755
|
Go to last page| Jump to page:
sucheta

Bhubaneswar, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1681
Jun 6, 2012
 
jus don care about what those mbbs people say....you know they are very jealous of physios..because physios get rapid placements in foreign countries and the chairs in their parliament are named after therapists...so ignore what those mbbs people say...they only want to harass you and pull you down...and when people try to pull you down that means you are above them...just study hard and do your masters in foreign then see what a rocking life you people have....!!!
binku

Lucknow, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1682
Jun 7, 2012
 
hi kidu what do you think would an mbbs girl marry a physio
chan

New Delhi, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1683
Jun 7, 2012
 
Indian wrote:
<quoted text>
...and you want to be called doctors...you shitty scums dont even have the basic ethics...to earn money you bastards want healthy people to fall ill and then come to you with their hard-earned cash..doctor is a very highly respectful term, you are not even fit enough to be called humans.
Go to Hell...Bastards...
haramkhor bhosadi ke tu hain kaun kutte teri aise bolne ki himmat kaise hui physio massage wale hote hain kya gaandu massage ke alawa bhi bahut sare subjects hum padte hain haramkhor
Kidu

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1684
Jun 7, 2012
 
wunderfull idea. She do Suction and I do massage LOL LOL
binku wrote:
hi kidu what do you think would an mbbs girl marry a physio
Love Physiotherapy

Delhi, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1685
Jun 8, 2012
 
Ehmiyat wrote:
1) When you do not have the right to prescribe or administer drugs, how does your service become on par with that of a medical doctor?
2) In countries like the US, there are even nurses with advanced preparations, called as nurse anesthetists and nurse practitioners etc. who perform tasks such as administering anesthesia to surgical patients, and prescribing drugs for minor ailments etc. What we see is that they still call them 'nurse practitioners', and do not brag that they are substitute doctors. They practice within their precise limits, and the medical community has never resented them.
3) If you claim the prefix Dr, would you support similar claims by laboratory technicians, occupational therapists, speech therapists, radiography technologists etc.? If all and sundry can add the tag, what's so special about it?(I can't stop laughing, thinking of the hospital barber coming up with a name tag that says "Dr.XYZ (HRT)" and explains HRT is for hair removal therapy.)
4) Howmuchever heavy the syllabus or rigorous the training of the ancillary health professions, it remains an undisputable fact that it's the medical doctor who is the team leader in providing health care to the patient. That is because of the comprehensive nature of his or her training and skills, of which the society is convinced. And this is the scene all over the world. Have you seen a nurse or a physio or any other ancillary personnel who functions as the team leader in a hospital? Why does that simple logic evade you?
5) In countries where factors other than a candidate's merit matter in admission to medical school, one's bound to see poor quality doctors. Will the physios claim that every single physio produced in every single college in this country, or elsewhere, is competent, knowledgeable and skillful?
6) Above all, even if your claim for the prefix is granted (God forbid a time when I have to walk in to an OPD and ask the "Dr" there, are you an MD or a physiotherapist?), what difference would it make on the quality of service you provide? Will a physio be providing superior quality physiotherapy with the tag of "Dr"? Wow then!
Answers:
1) All ailments cannot be treated with drugs e.g. Congenital Torticollis etc. Pharmacotherapy only is one part of medicine (refer Standard Medicine text books). Also, only prescribing medicine does not make one a doctor e.g. nurse Practiotners prescribing drugs but donot become doctors. Hence Prescribing drug is not essential criteria for being a doctor.
2) You gave answer to this question and previous one yourself that prescribing drug in not essential for being a doctor.
3) Physios, like Physicians do not have the right to decide status for other professions like lab techs, OTs, Speech therapists etc. which their respective professional organisations have to decide.
4) Yes, most of the disease management have medical doctor as team leader, but then dentists are not but still use Doctor, same logic for physios. BTW you would then call anesthetists, radiologist, ultrasonologist, pathologist etc as paramedics which is not the case.
5) Will the physicians/MCI claim that every single MBBS Degree-holder produced in every single college in this country, or elsewhere, is competent, knowledgeable and skillful? Specially after Satyamev Jayate? To further add-up, most of the universities/colleges providing physio courses are recognised and give admission on merit basis; and if a few are not following, UGC is taking action against them (as is taken against medical colleges following irregularites) and is a matter of improper regularisation of physio education for which all good physios want a central council by heart.(& will get it definitely)
6) The same difference it might have made on the quality of service the physicians provide. And if you think that prefixing Dr to a physician/dentist/surgeon do not make any difference on their servi ce, then what's the point of using it by them???
dinku

Delhi, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1686
Jun 13, 2012
 
iam an physio boy and i love an mbbs girl she is a very nice girl my love is true for her kaise bolu yaar plz help me kyunki meri kam aukaat ki wajah se kahi wo mujhe reject na karde plz help me
Sri Lankan

Colombo, Sri Lanka

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1688
Jun 15, 2012
 
samething happening in sri lanka. Medical doctors think health is a sole property of them and they are always making troubles to other health professions even they know nothing about the others health professions.
reesan

Delhi, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1689
Jun 20, 2012
 
Mujeeb wrote:
Physiatrist are a new speciality doctors who can effectively supervise physiotherapy program. So phsiotherapists cannot call themselves specialists..they are medicals.
i think u need to upgrade ur knowledge about physical therapy.check on net doctor of physiotherapy.
luku

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1690
Jun 20, 2012
 
Physios Rocks. mbbs sulks...
sandesh_jn

Nilambur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1691
Jun 21, 2012
 
I think the thousands of traditional birth attendants ('dai's) and midwives in India should get the priority in being called doctors, before physiotherapists. :-D
kriggys

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1692
Jun 21, 2012
 
whats up mbbs peeple? you want us to be your slaves everytime? like lab techs and xray people? come on guys, open up your vision. be broadminded. see the contributions of Physiotherapy.get a life
kriggys

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1693
Jun 21, 2012
 
you peeple get cuts from pharmacies, implant company xrays. You peeple like to cure osteorthrits by knee changing hip changings.we treat well with exercise Ultrasound, Diathermy and ointments. so you wont have to use your blades.so no commishions for surgerys. one day you will understand our importtance guys.your mbbs and other wurthless medicines will fail then Physiotherapy will shine
kamal

India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1694
Jun 21, 2012
 
physio r depends on their healing hands not on drugs....so that they r nt doctors .... I dont think this is right.... Absolutly they r doctors.....no doubt
Loh

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1695
Jun 21, 2012
 
well said Dr. Kriggys
kriggys wrote:
you peeple get cuts from pharmacies, implant company xrays. You peeple like to cure osteorthrits by knee changing hip changings.we treat well with exercise Ultrasound, Diathermy and ointments. so you wont have to use your blades.so no commishions for surgerys. one day you will understand our importtance guys.your mbbs and other wurthless medicines will fail then Physiotherapy will shine
sankar

United States

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1696
Jun 21, 2012
 
friends dont fight for the 2 words do u know about the Dr 's
m.d.(gen.med)doctor treating a neuro patient they didnt refer the patient to m.d neurology Dr. same like some example,
a neurosurgeon doing a spine surgery then what is the work for the orthopeadic surgeon, a orthopeadic surgeon fixing a fixation for mandibular fracture then y the dental surgeon, a gynecologist treating a peadiatric baby then y pediatrician, a pediatrician seeing a geratric cases & poisoning cases, a dental surgeon seeing a orthodentic,prosthodental, and other cases. cardiologist treating a pulmonology cases anasthetist doing a gynec surgery (nagerkovil),neurosurgeon doing a ent surgery , general surgeon doing a surgery for oncology patient then y surgical oncologist, ada theatre attender intubating the patient, pharmacist prescribing medicine not only Dr's even the physiothetapist teaching yoga,accupuncture,accupressure ,etc guys dont fight for aberration of letter that is nothing plz every body basically humans plz treat and refer the patient for the appropriate treatment plz dont make money in patient. u . we. fell one day for that think ur friend may be a gen.med,gen.sur,or physician, or neuro.sur. or dentist or physiotherapist plz refer the patient. PLZ DO UR WORK WHAT UR SPECIALITY OK IF NOT UR THE FORGERY MALPRACTIONER
sankar

United States

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1697
Jun 21, 2012
 
do u know now a days medicine and treatment I will explain u (my knowledge) a case of headache due to stress the case attend by a fresher Dr.x he examine thoroughly adviced medication.patient recovered . after a year Dr.x started a clinic the same patient came and same advice of new tablets that is AVAILABLE ONLY AT DR KNOWN MEDICAL SHOP.
the same patient came after 3 years (note Dr.x lab, Dr.x pharm Dr.x x-ray Dr.x ecg) patient adviced for routine lab inves,x-ray sinus, advised ecg, and the same old medications. after 10th year Dr.x started multispeciality hospital mri, ct, ultrasound, the same patient came now patient came same compliant advised for 1st c.t. then inform to the patient it is not clear so we take m.r.i results shows same normal but patient is not refer to other Dr. opthomologist to check vision . the fresher Dr. x forget assessment, differential diagnosis, Dr.x remember only one thing how we earn with this equipment (its looks like a finance company) this is promise true story a orthopeadic surgeon never touch the patient in the Dr room no assessment table but lot of guide working there coming out from the Dr. room sir x.ray that side scan this side x.ray, lab. plz stop fight for Dr. and behave like the fresher Dr. plz DO the Pt. need. earn money but do the right thing ok bye friends if it hurts any body iam sorry
Kidu

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1698
Jun 22, 2012
 
Thanx Brother you are correct
kriggys wrote:
you peeple get cuts from pharmacies, implant company xrays. You peeple like to cure osteorthrits by knee changing hip changings.we treat well with exercise Ultrasound, Diathermy and ointments. so you wont have to use your blades.so no commishions for surgerys. one day you will understand our importtance guys.your mbbs and other wurthless medicines will fail then Physiotherapy will shine
Kidu

Kannur, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1699
Jun 22, 2012
 

Judged:

3

2

Physios will save this country dont worry sarvan Wait till we get our Council
Saravan wrote:
Yes, of course physiotherapists are not doctors but one of the paramedics work with doctors. This kind of warning from medical bodies required in countries like india where one can purchase whatever they want including affix of "Dr", this is what physiotherapists have done, they have purchased indian politicians for lobby and law makers are breaking the same laws which they have made in parliment. Only god has to save this country.
kush hal

Pathanamthitta, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1700
Jun 23, 2012
 
Hey kidu kriggyz proud of you. These mbbs a..holes shud be shown their place
pavan

Bangalore, India

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1701
Jun 23, 2012
 
Fyzio gals really cute I am n luv wid a fyzio gal.

Tell me when this thread is updated:
(Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker

Send me an email

Showing posts 1,541 - 1,560 of1,755
|
Go to last page| Jump to page:
Type in your comments below
Name
(appears on your post)
Comments
Characters left: 4000
Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Daily Horoscope for May 23

Libra

You're in an idealistic mood today and only want to see the best in other people. This is typical Libran behaviour, because you aren't good at facing up to harsh reality at the best of times. Today, you're ready to believe that someone is a candidate for sainthood or that they're the best thing that's ever happened to you, regardless of whether it's true or not.

Get your Horoscope »