Idol Watch: The Top 12 Guys Hit the Stage

Feb 28, 2012 Full story: BroadwayWorld.com

Tonight on AMERICAN IDOL, the top 12 guys sang for your votes. The episode left us with many questions: Who'll make it through to the next round? What was the big surprise scheduled for the end of the show? Where's Simon Cowell when you need him? Find out now! Kicking things off is Reed Grimm.

Full Story
NuttyMusicLover

Brentwood, TN

#1 Feb 28, 2012
I thought tonight was horrible! First of all, the judges are irritating - Everyone in the competition is not "amazing". Eben was so bad that I was blushing for him, yet the judges actually praised him for being so good! Keep judging like this and you won't have any viewers - Americans/Music Lovers are not that stupid! Secondly, the guys were just "average" - Joshua L is the only one that was seriously "wow"!!! I pray to God the girls are better otherwise I may just tune out. SAD to see a great show tank!
I B Goofy

Hampton, VA

#2 Feb 29, 2012
I thought the same thing. Not impresses at all. It was like all hoooohummmm karaokie. I kinda like the last guy. I dont think he'll win, but I enjoyed his song last night. Its like a "lovefest" with the judges. They looooooove everybody. They're all magnificant. They all have a gift from god. Blaaaaablaaaaablaaaaa. I'll watch the gals...then wait for Dancing with the Stars and see how that starts.:o)
Anonymous

La Habra, CA

#3 Mar 2, 2012
The girls were even worse than the guys.

Cannot believe Skylar and Hollie got through!

Phillip and Shannon are my favorites.

That is a seriously skanky tattoo on Erika's back.

Tell me when this thread is updated:

Subscribe Now Add to my Tracker

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Reality TV Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Bruce Jenner Sex Change: Hot Pink Nails - Trans... 15 min Butch Jenner 11
Kelly Clarkson: My life couldn't be better Fri Pam St Clement 1
Gordon Ramsay loses pub rent battle Jan 23 jules 3
So Long Teutuls! American Chopper Cancelled By ... (Nov '12) Jan 23 buginfested 40
Keith Lemon: I'll retire when I'm 50 Jan 22 djsnf 1
'Bachelorette' Emily Maynard and Jef Holm break up (Oct '12) Jan 20 Yepi 67
Looking at Top 40 Radio's Decade of Change, Thr... Jan 20 Winston Grooves 1
japanese mom son sex game shows are real? (Feb '12) Nov '14 kumarkumar 52
More from around the web