Dr. Phil Family Update 2012 Katherine's Lie! Baby daddy already married!

After nine years of dysfunction, the Stehl family has another new scandal to overcome: Katherine celebrates new baby Paul; problem is described fiance Paul Troilo will need to divorce his current wife, Brittany Mitchell Troilo, before he can be Katherine's fiance. How will Katherine explain this? Or, does Dr. Phil and the Stehl family bother explaining this oversight, or just keep pulling the covers over this inconvenient truth?

Thank you slayer for starting this thread. Because the DP show will NEVER publicize this fact.

Anyone who is interesting in learning more about the details of this miserable situation, go to the thread: Dr. Phil Family: The Trouble with Alexandra and read from November 2011 onwards.

Katherine's supposed fiance and baby daddy Paul J. Troilo has been married since 2005, there are several posts from his current wife, Brittany, that are few interesting. Brittany tells us that Katherine was very aware of Paul's martial status and played him off her shack-up at the time, resulting in some violence between the two guys.

Way to go Katherine! Sink those claws of yours into another guy before letting go of your current piece. Katherine is more like Alexandra every day!

Katherine and her dysfunctional family gleefully announce the birth of Paul Jr. on the last Dr. Phil Family Update in Nov. 2011. Erin and Marty tell DP's audience that at first they were unhappy with Katherine's unwed pregnancy news, but changed their minds, and believe Paul is a wonderful young man. Oops, except, young man is a suspected weed dealer and is already married with a (at time) six year old son. How did he explain that? Maybe that he's a Big Brother...bongs away!

Katherine, like her sister, sure knows how to pick a baby daddy!

A reply transferred from 'The Trouble with Alexandra:'

Poor Erin, either she is finally resigned that her daughters are destined to a life of bad choices & decisions, and now she can do nothing but provide cover for them. Which is what I think she's doing for Katherine.

Erin and Dr. Phoney appear to be doing a great job of hiding Paul Troilo's marital status from most of the world. Looks like their plan is to marginalize Brittany's claims as effectively as possible.

Example: look what 'Anonymous' tried to do here on Topix -- portray Brittany as some kind of criminal, crazy, and neglectful mother who deserves to have her son removed from her care -- as if that had anything to do with her husband's marital status. Thankfully most of us are not so easily fooled, since most of us don't respect Dr. Phoney anyway.

Think about it: no matter what we know about this situation, how much we discuss it here, how effectively can we communicate this scandalous lie beyond us, when giant media manipulators like Dr. Phil, and Oprah Winfrey, whose production studios and syndication conglomerate owns his show, desires to kill the truth? Plus they have the media 'reach' to portray this any way they wish.

Dr. Phil and his show are nothing but a professional lying machine with a single goal: to make money, regardless of how negatively those lies affect innocent people.

The only reason I think Alex may be in rehab is the tone of Erin's tweets, and her reluctance to provide any REAL answer to the few questions she allows to be posted re: Alex's current situation. Normally she would provide some answer like -- don't know how or where she is. Now, the tweets are more secretive, like she knows, but can't disclose anything.

You may be right about the 'tidy bow' plan of Dr. Phoney and Erin. DP and his staff may believe the first 'Dr. Phil Family' needs a 'happy ending' to all these nine years of drama, so they'll create one: Alex out of rehab; Katherine marries her dream guy and baby daddy; Erin and Marty continue to rear and dote on their 3 beautiful grandchildren!

Since few, beyond us, know about Brittany and her son, Dr. Phoney doesn't have to address them. Or, they can include Brittany's son and just explain him as Paul's from an earlier marriage.

Erin Stehl has a twitter page where she posts photos of new grandson, Paul --

The more photos of baby Paul I see the more those 'ears' look like Paul J. Troilo senior's ears. Brittany is being 'shut out' in more ways than one. If Dr. Phil and Erin continue to ignore her and just don't make any negative comments about her, then she won't be able to bring in an attorney to sue for 'defamation.'

Not sure if she has any legal leg to stand on regarding Erin including her son in family photos if Paul Sr. has his son over at his 'fiance's' parents' home. The behavior may be slimy, but it's not illegal. Just because all the Stehls and Dr. Phil are disgusting, miserable, rancid, putrid, filthy, opportunistic scum, doesn't mean there is anything Brittany can do about it.

At least Brittany can find comfort in knowing that a marriage between her ex-husband (after divorce) and Katherine Stehl is destined to dysfunctional failure.

What the hell is wrong with these girls Alexandra and Katherine? Why are they so screwed up? Were they molested as children or something? Seriously, what happened?

Nancy wrote:

What the hell is wrong with these girls Alexandra and Katherine? Why are they so screwed up? Were they molested as children or something? Seriously, what happened?

My guess would be SPOILED. I also wonder if they were played against eachother. They both seem (at least to me) that the sister's try to "out-do" the other in effort to get their parents attention, even if it means negative attention. But they may have had more sinnister acts committed against them aswell. I've never heard that though.

Anyone want to wager that Dr. Phil will not be addressing news from Katherine's 'situation' during these next two episodes about the family?

I'll stick my neck out ant predict that we'll get some 'happy lies' about how well Katherine is doing with her baby Paul Jr. and what a great dad her baby daddy is -- taped scenes stuck on towards the end of episodes beyond these two upcoming ones this week.

Will the shows reveal: 1) did Katherine complete her Jr. College coursework -- NOT! How does a pot-dependent knot-head like Katherine scrap together the ambition to attend classes?

2) Will dishonest Dr. Phil finally reveal that Paul Troilo Sr. was married when shacked up with and (?) possibly creating a baby with slimy Katherine?

3) Where's the DNA test? Are they even still together -- whatever that means these days?

Can't change what you don't acknowledge, hey, Dr. Phil? Or will you simply continue to play along with Erin and cover for Katherine's bad choices?

Slayer wrote:

Anyone want to wager that Dr. Phil will not be addressing news from Katherine's 'situation' during these next two episodes about the family?
I'll stick my neck out ant predict that we'll get some 'happy lies' about how well Katherine is doing with her baby Paul Jr. and what a great dad her baby daddy is -- taped scenes stuck on towards the end of episodes beyond these two upcoming ones this week.
Will the shows reveal: 1) did Katherine complete her Jr. College coursework -- NOT! How does a pot-dependent knot-head like Katherine scrap together the ambition to attend classes?
2) Will dishonest Dr. Phil finally reveal that Paul Troilo Sr. was married when shacked up with and (?) possibly creating a baby with slimy Katherine?
3) Where's the DNA test? Are they even still together -- whatever that means these days?
Can't change what you don't acknowledge, hey, Dr. Phil? Or will you simply continue to play along with Erin and cover for Katherine's bad choices?

I'm wondering if they are even together? No evidence that they are. Kathrine should be ashamed of herself. All the guys in the world and she just had to have one that was already someone else's Daddy? Heartless. I guess I have slightly mixed feelings for the bony homewrecker. I can see how she and her new illegitimate child mean didly to the Stehls and that's kind of sad. But then I see her being her selfish chinless self and creating drama, making men fight over her bony flat butt, and then wrecking apart another woman's home.

I DOUBT they will stay together--it just won't happen. Almost never does. Can't build a house on a rotten foundation. I think within two years she will be with a new man, hopefully one that is available and not 'stolen.' I think it is extremely obnoxious how she named her illegitimate child "Paul Jr.," when actually, Paul Troilo ALREADY HAS AN ELDEST FIRST CHILD. Either the bony broad with the receded chin either didn't know or didn't care that the Jr is always reserved for the first male son. Subsequent illegitimate s are not supposed to have that honor. Your son is NOT firstborn, bony.