Pakistan plans to revoke Afghans' refugee status could displace 3 million

Muddy mess becomes muddier...do enjoy yourselves!?!?!!??!

Its time for US to entertain 3 Million+ Afghans for a 3 coming 3 Decades like Pakistan

Ship em over to usa....

Pakistan destroyed their country and should build their country now. Pakistan chased away Russia and now finding it hard to push America out. Respect Muslim bhai.

Our fk'ing government better not even think about bringing them here.

It's alright to get millions of Dollars from UN to feed refugees but when time comes to look alter them Pakistan is running away. Destroyed their country with the help of Foreign powers. Shame.

PAKISTAN spends 23 Billion $ So far in 3 Decades on Afghan Refugees Alone none in World Help or contribute directly to Pakistan on This ... whatever UN Spend its unofficial not VIA Pakistan Govt. they spend it on their own (Not an earth near to 23 Billion $ ) which Pakistan Spend so far on a cost of its own Economy - US must has to pay the Highest Share as Pakistan Fight its Proxy war in 80s then against Russians in Afghanistan and Pakistan is responsible of breaking apart Russia formally USSR into several States

mICHEAL wrote:

PAKISTAN spends 23 Billion $ So far in 3 Decades on Afghan Refugees Alone none in World Help or contribute directly to Pakistan on This ... whatever UN Spend its unofficial not VIA Pakistan Govt. they spend it on their own (Not an earth near to 23 Billion $) which Pakistan Spend so far on a cost of its own Economy - US must has to pay the Highest Share as Pakistan Fight its Proxy war in 80s then against Russians in Afghanistan and Pakistan is responsible of breaking apart Russia formally USSR into several States

It's all guess work. Pakistan's whole economy is not as big as this. Pakistan will never spend a dollar on any nationality. Was it no Pakistan who attacked Afganistan to send Russian backed Govt into exile and destroyed their country. Pakistan wanted US dollars and attacked it's neighbour destroying their country and ruined it just to change the regimen. They were happy. Now it will take them centuries once you stop your intervention.

30+ years is too much burden on Pakistan...

If US really want to with draw troops from Afghanistan , US must participate in return of Afghan refugees from Pakistan in their own country...

Afghan refugees in Pakistan could help to build Afghanistan they have learnt and trained in Pakistan...

They would promote Afghan-Pakistan real brother relations many are born in Pakistan....

Its time to US to help them in settling back in Afghanistan...

I am in favor of Immigrating all them in USA as US is responsible for this mess mostly so its about high time to pay them for their suffer which US is responsible

Only they can be responsible for their suffering. No one forced them to leave their country and no one forced them to stay in Pakistan and no one forced them to kill there own people in a civil war. The Mullas were the ones that went to USA begging for weapons to fight the PDPA Government in Afghanistan. They should take responsibility for there own actions.

Savior wrote:

I am in favor of Immigrating all them in USA as US is responsible for this mess mostly so its about high time to pay them for their suffer which US is responsible

Nobody cares what you say Neandertal.

Savior wrote:

I am in favor of Immigrating all them in USA as US is responsible for this mess mostly so its about high time to pay them for their suffer which US is responsible

Pakistan is responsible for years messing about in Afganistan's affairs. They are the one responsible for millions of death and destruction. Nobody looks at the history because it's Pakistan the USA's agent in Asia.

Humhainna wrote:

<quoted text>
Pakistan is responsible for years messing about in Afganistan's affairs. They are the one responsible for millions of death and destruction. Nobody looks at the history because it's Pakistan the USA's agent in Asia.

If Pakistan has that much control then why thousands Pakistani peoples have died?

Pakistan is not USA's agent but US has agents in Pakistan...

Star wrote:

<quoted text>
If Pakistan has that much control then why thousands Pakistani peoples have died?
Pakistan is not USA's agent but US has agents in Pakistan...

You only know what your Govt wants you to know. Innocent thousands of Pakistani's lost their live and are losing still because of your Govt policies.

Sherjat wrote:

Only they can be responsible for their suffering. No one forced them to leave their country and no one forced them to stay in Pakistan and no one forced them to kill there own people in a civil war. The Mullas were the ones that went to USA begging for weapons to fight the PDPA Government in Afghanistan. They should take responsibility for there own actions.

. Afghans didnt run to some foreign land, they went to their own land, on the other side of Durand line. As for Pakistanis, they got rich from Afghan, misery, they think, if afghans continue their suffering, they will get even richer. But those days are over, they try to double cross, the Americans, now they are going, to pay for their foolishness. Pakistan can't even feed their own population, let alone feeding afghans. Get out of your fantasy .

mICHEAL wrote:

PAKISTAN spends 23 Billion $ So far in 3 Decades on Afghan Refugees Alone none in World Help or contribute directly to Pakistan on This ... whatever UN Spend its unofficial not VIA Pakistan Govt. they spend it on their own (Not an earth near to 23 Billion $) which Pakistan Spend so far on a cost of its own Economy - US must has to pay the Highest Share as Pakistan Fight its Proxy war in 80s then against Russians in Afghanistan and Pakistan is responsible of breaking apart Russia formally USSR into several States

. Pakistan can't even feed themselves, their country is not worth 23 billion, how can they spend this imaginary money that they don't have? Afghans fought the Russians, not Pakis. Pakistan is only responsible for begging money from u.s., and they thought they are so smart, that they can double cross, the Americans. Now thats real funny part to all this. Pakistan have to now fight for its existence, instead of acting, like a hot shot.

Afghans fought with Russia is a joke. Who gave training and who provided money and who is still training Afgans, the world know's. UN always provides money for refugees. Whose soil is being used for the supply of various things to invaders.

From experience i can tell you that it is futile to discuss anything with Afghans they are illiterate peasants. They will never agree to facts and anyway they cannot decide there future. It is all a part of the Great game and in the future regionally either India or Pakistan will domiante Afghan. They are too weak, cruel, unreasonable and incompetent to adminsiter themselves.

Global players will also be active.

Afghans never fought the Russians. The USA controlled the whole operation from start to finish by paying for the refugees, paying the tribal warlords and Mujahideen leaders, providing weapons and training and logistical and strategic help.

Afghan sold there own land and our now crying and blaming others for there own folly. Finally it is a known fact that Durand Line was made by the British in 1893 after they conquered Punjab as before the British this land was all a part of the Kingdom of Maharaja Ranjit Singh. After the British left all the land west and north of Durand should have gone to the decendents of Maharaja and his state. So it is not Afghan Land. Afghanistan was itselrf a part of India, before the Turks rapred and killed them.