Local: Los Angeles, CA  (change)

 | 

Join the Topix community today: 

Sign Up

 | 

Sign In

Advertisment
Top Stories

Can Organized Religion Survive Itself?

created by: Zerotollerance | Thursday Jul 24

Click on an option to vote

24

votes

  • Posted in the Top Stories Forum
  • Hot Polls | Recent Polls
  • yes
  • no

Comments

Showing posts 1 - 15 of 15

“Fine Speech,What do we do now?”

Joined: Jun 23, 2008
Comments: 54
Pennsylvania
ISP Location: Palmerton, PA
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1
Thursday Jul 24
 
The reason for this poll is to gather some insight on organized religions.
Most religions have many different sects, and in my observation, these different sects can get heated about their beliefs that differ from another sect. Weather it be the Christian, Protestant-Catholic differnence or the Muslim, Shi'i-Sunni differences, I would like to know why these differences can, in some cases lead to extremes, sometimes violence.
The Dalai Lama was in Pennsylvania recently. Not being a religious man, I attended his lecture just out of curiosity.
In front of the venue there were monks from a Buddhist sect protesting the Dalai Lama, calling him a "liar"!
My reaction was disappointment.
I thought to myself, "damn, even the Buddhist can't agree with each other"!
This leaves me with the question, "Can religion survive itself"? Or will it destroy itself from the inside out?
looking forward to your insights.

“but not Anti-others”

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Comments: 268
I actually have none
ISP Location: Oklahoma City, OK
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#2
Thursday Jul 24
 

Judged:

1

1

1

Hey Zero - first I have to tell you that I love the pic and Amadeus is one of my favorite movies of all time. It has got to be one of the best examples of what resentment can do to a person and Antonio Salieri, briliant in his own right, spent his life comparing himself to someone else...well, I'm not telling you anything you don't already know..lol

I have a lot of opinions about organized religion. My ex-husband was a fundamentalist abusive man who would quote Bible verses at me after calling me a whore and then telling me where in the Bible it said that I was. Took awhile to get over that.

The reason I'm involved in an organized doctrine today is fairly complicated. I have been the recipient of a few "miracles", the kinds of things that leave me no question that there is a God. Why did I get these miracles? I do not know. I know they were desires of my heart but I do not remember praying for them.

You spoke of different sects getting heated about their beliefs. I have been witness to such activity and have at times been appaled by the behavior of supposed "spiritual" people, including myself. I don't have the answer but I do believe that there are supposed to be different sects, different doctrines and different religions. We are not intended to be the same (Tower of Babel).

The God of my understanding created everything and everyone and knows the hairs on everypersons head that ever existed. My job is to live a life that honors my Savior and tell anyone who will listen about Jesus.
What is done with that information is up to the individual. I have friends who are believers, non-believers and some are on the fence. I try to love them all equally and it is not my place to tell them they are right or wrong. I live my life the way I believe I'm supposed to. I'm not the pageant type but I would like world peace. Hope this helps. Thanks for the thread.

“Fine Speech,What do we do now?”

Joined: Jun 23, 2008
Comments: 54
Pennsylvania
ISP Location: Palmerton, PA
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#3
Thursday Jul 24
 
Pro Christian wrote:
Hey Zero - first I have to tell you that I love the pic and Amadeus is one of my favorite movies of all time. It has got to be one of the best examples of what resentment can do to a person and Antonio Salieri, briliant in his own right, spent his life comparing himself to someone else...well, I'm not telling you anything you don't already know..lol
I have a lot of opinions about organized religion. My ex-husband was a fundamentalist abusive man who would quote Bible verses at me after calling me a whore and then telling me where in the Bible it said that I was. Took awhile to get over that.
The reason I'm involved in an organized doctrine today is fairly complicated. I have been the recipient of a few "miracles", the kinds of things that leave me no question that there is a God. Why did I get these miracles? I do not know. I know they were desires of my heart but I do not remember praying for them.
You spoke of different sects getting heated about their beliefs. I have been witness to such activity and have at times been appaled by the behavior of supposed "spiritual" people, including myself. I don't have the answer but I do believe that there are supposed to be different sects, different doctrines and different religions. We are not intended to be the same (Tower of Babel).
The God of my understanding created everything and everyone and knows the hairs on everypersons head that ever existed. My job is to live a life that honors my Savior and tell anyone who will listen about Jesus.
What is done with that information is up to the individual. I have friends who are believers, non-believers and some are on the fence. I try to love them all equally and it is not my place to tell them they are right or wrong. I live my life the way I believe I'm supposed to. I'm not the pageant type but I would like world peace. Hope this helps. Thanks for the thread.
Thanks for you input.
It's a pleasure to read your posts.
What I would really like to get at is why the extreme attitudes?
For Christians, as an example the goal is salvation through Jesus.
Why, does it seem that the path, rather than the goal, is given more importance?
This is what I have trouble understanding.
The disagreements between Sects over this "path" has lead to some pretty nasty stuff over time, the Reformation, Northern Ireland, etc.
All that extreme stuff aside, what leads a person to choose a certain denomination? What lead you to choose one path as opposed to the other, if the ultimate goal is the same?
If I'm being too personal I appologize.
It's just that when I can get involved in a religious discussion that's on an intelligent and civil plane, I really try to get as much insight from the person as possible.
I just want "know"! Sometimes it's a curse.

“but not Anti-others”

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Comments: 268
I actually have none
ISP Location: Oklahoma City, OK
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#4
Thursday Jul 24
 

Judged:

1

Zerotollerance wrote:
<quoted text>
Thanks for you input.
It's a pleasure to read your posts.
What I would really like to get at is why the extreme attitudes?
For Christians, as an example the goal is salvation through Jesus.
Why, does it seem that the path, rather than the goal, is given more importance?
This is what I have trouble understanding.
The disagreements between Sects over this "path" has lead to some pretty nasty stuff over time, the Reformation, Northern Ireland, etc.
All that extreme stuff aside, what leads a person to choose a certain denomination? What lead you to choose one path as opposed to the other, if the ultimate goal is the same?
If I'm being too personal I appologize.
It's just that when I can get involved in a religious discussion that's on an intelligent and civil plane, I really try to get as much insight from the person as possible.
I just want "know"! Sometimes it's a curse.
I understand your dilema. What motivates the Mussilini's, Hitler's, Mansons and Al Quaida, ad infinitum... not withstanding the anti-thiests who go to extremes.

Many believe that these people are psychotic, in my ex-husbands case I would have to agree. I think they begin in an honest attempt to obtain "perfection" thinking that will bring them closer to God, or prove there is not God.

Things like the Romans crucifying the Jews for not worshiping Ceasar, the Egyptians slaughtered their slaves, the Spanish Inquisition was just downright pathetic and American slavery is still an embarassment to this day. I could go on and on but I believe in trying to live beyond the mistakes and doing better than out predecessors. As for our modern day fanatics, its as if they are possessed by evil. I will not name evil as I think it has too many names but I believe it does exist unfortunately.

You speak of the path to salvation and for many I believe that the simplicity of it is part of the problem. People go to revivals and such and get all hopped up on emotion, accept Christ (or the diety du'jour) and when they leave they receive no education on what just happened so when the high wears off they are more bitter than before and become angry at the very God they just gave their soul to (speaking generally of course)

The disagreement among the sects is necessary and just a part of the plan. Arguments are the only way to get out points across no?(hold on,my tongue is stuck in my cheek)

As far as choosing a denomination, I attend a church that preaches Grace. There is an international governing board and I can trace every cent I give to charities all over the world. The preachers are appointed and not chosen and they are moved frequently so the emphasis stays on Jesus (hopefully). The small churches that cannot afford to maintain themselves are taken care of by the larger (more affluent ones) so that there is a church in most every town no matter how rural and now we are spreading all over the world, for example, the church I attend supports a church in Africa with our excess. I believe that the church I attend does its best to do as Jesus taught. It is not without it's problems and faults but it is the closest thing to what I believe and it is where I feel comfortable.

I truly believe that when you are where you are supposed to be you know it in your heart. Till then, never give up the search. I was 38 years old when I found what I feel to be the truth.

Neat thread!

“Fine Speech,What do we do now?”

Joined: Jun 23, 2008
Comments: 54
Pennsylvania
ISP Location: Palmerton, PA
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#5
Thursday Jul 24
 
Pro Christian wrote:
<quoted text>
I understand your dilema. What motivates the Mussilini's, Hitler's, Mansons and Al Quaida, ad infinitum... not withstanding the anti-thiests who go to extremes.
Many believe that these people are psychotic, in my ex-husbands case I would have to agree. I think they begin in an honest attempt to obtain "perfection" thinking that will bring them closer to God, or prove there is not God.
Things like the Romans crucifying the Jews for not worshiping Ceasar, the Egyptians slaughtered their slaves, the Spanish Inquisition was just downright pathetic and American slavery is still an embarassment to this day. I could go on and on but I believe in trying to live beyond the mistakes and doing better than out predecessors. As for our modern day fanatics, its as if they are possessed by evil. I will not name evil as I think it has too many names but I believe it does exist unfortunately.
You speak of the path to salvation and for many I believe that the simplicity of it is part of the problem. People go to revivals and such and get all hopped up on emotion, accept Christ (or the diety du'jour) and when they leave they receive no education on what just happened so when the high wears off they are more bitter than before and become angry at the very God they just gave their soul to (speaking generally of course)
The disagreement among the sects is necessary and just a part of the plan. Arguments are the only way to get out points across no?(hold on,my tongue is stuck in my cheek)
As far as choosing a denomination, I attend a church that preaches Grace. There is an international governing board and I can trace every cent I give to charities all over the world. The preachers are appointed and not chosen and they are moved frequently so the emphasis stays on Jesus (hopefully). The small churches that cannot afford to maintain themselves are taken care of by the larger (more affluent ones) so that there is a church in most every town no matter how rural and now we are spreading all over the world, for example, the church I attend supports a church in Africa with our excess. I believe that the church I attend does its best to do as Jesus taught. It is not without it's problems and faults but it is the closest thing to what I believe and it is where I feel comfortable.
I truly believe that when you are where you are supposed to be you know it in your heart. Till then, never give up the search. I was 38 years old when I found what I feel to be the truth.
Neat thread!
Wow, Thank you! You are being a big help.
I hope your "ex" realizes what an intelligent, thoughtful, mate he has lost.
Don't worry, I'm not fishing for a date! LOL
Just paying an innocent compliment.

“but not Anti-others”

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Comments: 268
I actually have none
ISP Location: Oklahoma City, OK
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#6
Friday Jul 25
 
Zerotollerance wrote:
<quoted text>
Wow, Thank you! You are being a big help.
I hope your "ex" realizes what an intelligent, thoughtful, mate he has lost.
Don't worry, I'm not fishing for a date! LOL
Just paying an innocent compliment.
Glad to be of help and no, my ex tells me that I'm still a slut but now I'm ignorant as well and hellbound for sure....such a nice guy. And as for fishing, I know a lot of bait but I've been dragged up on the boat by a real nice fisherman who thinks I am thoughtful and intelligent (at least thats what I tell him to think) but thanks for the compliment. Your a joy to banter with.

“LISTENING NOW”

Joined: Mon Jul 21
Comments: 165
Warren Mi.
ISP Location: Warren, MI
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#7
Saturday Jul 26
 
It came about ten thousand years ago as a way to control the frieghtened masses. As long as we stay frightend religion will live. Sure it did some good things for mankind in laying the foundations for civil laws and basic public decorum. But the other side is that it did more to teach intollerance of others.
I believe it's a shame we have not been able to put away this crutch for social concience, and grown to see what men are capable of. The need for mythical dieties is at an end for sure, just not yet. Perhaps E.T. could take place of the old fables, makes about as much sense to me as any other wives tales told by the old books.

“but not Anti-others”

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Comments: 268
I actually have none
ISP Location: Oklahoma City, OK
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#8
Sunday Jul 27
 
Alex G wrote:
It came about ten thousand years ago as a way to control the frieghtened masses. As long as we stay frightend religion will live. Sure it did some good things for mankind in laying the foundations for civil laws and basic public decorum. But the other side is that it did more to teach intollerance of others.
I believe it's a shame we have not been able to put away this crutch for social concience, and grown to see what men are capable of. The need for mythical dieties is at an end for sure, just not yet. Perhaps E.T. could take place of the old fables, makes about as much sense to me as any other wives tales told by the old books.
First let me say that I'm saddened by the fact that you (or anyone else) lives in fear. Especially one perpetrated by a sect or doctrine. Second, life is what you chose it to be and if you want to be "Angry Man" then your chances of being happy are very slim indeed. Maybe you can find a mythical creature that makes you not so fearful and angry or try something else. I chose differently than you do and from what you write it appears that I am happier. Glad to help if you need it!

“LISTENING NOW”

Joined: Mon Jul 21
Comments: 165
Warren Mi.
ISP Location: Warren, MI
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#9
Sunday Jul 27
 
Pro Christian wrote:
<quoted text>
First let me say that I'm saddened by the fact that you (or anyone else) lives in fear. Especially one perpetrated by a sect or doctrine. Second, life is what you chose it to be and if you want to be "Angry Man" then your chances of being happy are very slim indeed. Maybe you can find a mythical creature that makes you not so fearful and angry or try something else. I chose differently than you do and from what you write it appears that I am happier. Glad to help if you need it!
Dont be so fooled by the dramatics. It's like a stage name, a persona, Just a face and name made to enforce drama. Do you think professional wrestlers are all hyped up and crazy all the time,I doubt not. But if you are highly religious I can understand how you were dooped by such an incredulous piece of media fakery. You have been led your whole life to believe in the obviously untrue.
If your faith gives you so much in your life it's ok, just sad. Sad that you must look to an intangable band of mysticism to fullfill yourself with.Humanity needs to learn that all answers to life come from within, not outdated scripts.

“LISTENING NOW”

Joined: Mon Jul 21
Comments: 165
Warren Mi.
ISP Location: Warren, MI
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#10
Sunday Jul 27
 
My only fear is that religious dogma will be the undoing of civilization. Billions have suffered for a millenia, over who heard the word of a omnipotent being. Over who was converted, and who was not. Religion is now just a devise meant to divide and conquer. Religious texts are meant for those who can, and cannot think for themselves. I can think for myself thankyou.

“but not Anti-others”

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Comments: 268
I actually have none
ISP Location: Oklahoma City, OK
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#11
Monday Jul 28
 
Alex G wrote:
<quoted text>
Dont be so fooled by the dramatics. It's like a stage name, a persona, Just a face and name made to enforce drama. Do you think professional wrestlers are all hyped up and crazy all the time,I doubt not. But if you are highly religious I can understand how you were dooped by such an incredulous piece of media fakery. You have been led your whole life to believe in the obviously untrue.
If your faith gives you so much in your life it's ok, just sad. Sad that you must look to an intangable band of mysticism to fullfill yourself with.Humanity needs to learn that all answers to life come from within, not outdated scripts.
Professional wrestlers? please.

We are our bumper stickers - what we present to the world is who we are. For you to assume I have spend my whole life beling led to believe anything takes a mighty large EGO which ususally is accompanied by a lower than normal self esteem. I became a Christian at the age of 38 by choice not by force. You do your thing and I'll do mine. I assume nothing about you except what you present.

“but not Anti-others”

Joined: Jun 26, 2008
Comments: 268
I actually have none
ISP Location: Oklahoma City, OK
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#12
Monday Jul 28
 
Alex G wrote:
My only fear is that religious dogma will be the undoing of civilization. Billions have suffered for a millenia, over who heard the word of a omnipotent being. Over who was converted, and who was not. Religion is now just a devise meant to divide and conquer. Religious texts are meant for those who can, and cannot think for themselves. I can think for myself thankyou.
Good for you!

“LISTENING NOW”

Joined: Mon Jul 21
Comments: 165
Warren Mi.
ISP Location: Warren, MI
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#13
Monday Jul 28
 
Pro Christian wrote:
<quoted text>
Professional wrestlers? please.
We are our bumper stickers - what we present to the world is who we are. For you to assume I have spend my whole life beling led to believe anything takes a mighty large EGO which ususally is accompanied by a lower than normal self esteem. I became a Christian at the age of 38 by choice not by force. You do your thing and I'll do mine. I assume nothing about you except what you present.
If you posted these facts earlier I admit to ignorance. I had assumed incorrectly that you were a lifelong christian. Your life of course "is" your choice, as my life is mine. By the way I really do love how my pic and profile set people off, even if it is in the negative.
Tiger
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#14
Saturday Aug 2
 
The question beggers itself, actually

“LISTENING NOW”

Joined: Mon Jul 21
Comments: 165
Warren Mi.
ISP Location: Warren, MI
|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#15
Sunday Aug 3
 
It will survive just so long as televangelists keep old ladies sending in thier social security checks every month. Those guy's are buying souls for the lord. One of them is worth 75,000,000 bucks, say's god want's him to be rich. What a crooked evil basterd.
Showing posts 1 - 15 of 15
Type in your comments to post to the forum
Name
(appears on your post)
Comments
Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Other Recent Top Stories Discussions
Topic Updated Last By Comments
80's Music..... 3 min Southern Rock 364
Poll: Should people on food stamp be able buy junk food? 3 min on food stam... 3929
American Soldiers Rock 2 3 min Chicago Poet 3 19673
Why I’m no longer a Christian 4 min NorCal88 10847
Women, Do Not Marry An American Man, Period******* 4 min paintedquote 8140
Roman Catholic church only true church, says Va... (from Jul '07) 4 min Oriana 43685
Poll: why most white women prefer black men(the truth) (from Nov '07) 4 min dee white 7507