Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning: Who's the Best? - Part II

Jamil wrote:

<quoted text>
Whatever you are smoking i want some...It took peyton manning 2 wideouts that can be #1s on most other teams, a tightend with receiver speed, and 5 plus years of chemistry building to win a superbowl.Considering he is surrounded by all 1st round picks he should perform the way he his. But look at brady. Never really had the kind of receiving core indy had and has 3 superbowls. They are both great quaterbacks but the fact is brady has done more with less.

did you watch him this season harrison out the whole year with wayne and moorehead and all those and still have better stats except tds than brady.
manning built his team from 3-13 to a superbowl team. did u forget brady was given the job because of drew bledsoe's injury. he might not even be playing if bledsoe was still healthy

Bianco Sadler wrote:

I am a die heart Colts fan but I think tom brady is better than peyton manning. the reason why i think that is because tom brady has way more rings than manning. what is the point of playing with the greatest stats but no wins or rings. its all about winning not stats. remember u can be famous and rich but not happy at the same time.

Robert Horry has 6 NBA rings is he the best forward of all time?????
Trent dilfer has a ring is he better than Marino who has 0?

LaserRocketArm wrote:

<quoted text>
Yes, you keep telling yourself that, d-bag. We'll see in the end who wraps up all the league records and SB Rings. I think the heat is getting to ya'. What a fool!

You seem like the fool I think that most of us all agree that Tom brady is a overrated selfish Jerk just like you

I Love Mannings wrote:

<quoted text>
You seem like the fool I think that most of us all agree that Tom brady is a overrated selfish Jerk just like you

And how many Manning blow-up dolls you do have? More than 5? Yeahh, I thought so...

Do you do the t-bagging, or do you let the blow-up doll t-bag YOU?! LOL...

Happy Latex Humping, HOMO!

LaserRocketArm wrote:

<quoted text>
And how many Manning blow-up dolls you do have? More than 5? Yeahh, I thought so...
Do you do the t-bagging, or do you let the blow-up doll t-bag YOU?! LOL...
Happy Latex Humping, HOMO!

lol someones mature. you don't deserve oxygen :(

Cssie ur wrong. they r not good friends at all. infact, they wont even shake hands after a game. ive been a colts fan for the last 9 years. wen peyton manning came from college. ive been tryin to decide who is better. and ive decided after reading many different arguments, that this is a uncomparible thing. its all about who u like more. for me its peyton manning, so for all of u who say 1 is better than the other, that is UNTRUE.

JESUS wrote:

<quoted text>
lol someones mature. you don't deserve oxygen :(

You talkin' like you're out of breath from blowing up that doll of yours. Take a deep breath and get on top and enjoy the ride...

jonathon COLTS MAN wrote:

Cssie ur wrong. they r not good friends at all. infact, they wont even shake hands after a game. ive been a colts fan for the last 9 years. wen peyton manning came from college. ive been tryin to decide who is better. and ive decided after reading many different arguments, that this is a uncomparible thing. its all about who u like more. for me its peyton manning, so for all of u who say 1 is better than the other, that is UNTRUE.

Couldn't agree with you more. There is no comparison. Brady is far superior to the blow-hard Manning. Facts speak for themselves and when all is said and done, the homos who wished they were the ones who Manning t-bagged in college will see the light, or maybe not...

LOL.

Tom Brady is way better than Peytons bitch ass. Peyton cries too much. Brady has more rings more superbowl wins more wins regularly. Most importantly hes been to the superbowl more

Hollis wrote:

Peyton is by far better, he has beter numbers, he has the most recent superbowl ring, and he has made his team great through out the years without a great defense.

You suck Brady is by far better , i like Manning but brady has more wins and scores more tds

peyton wins in stats overall
well isn't Tom's 2007 better than peyton's 2004
well peyton still wins in passer rating, yards per attempt, completion, and has had less attempts in both thier magical seasons
rings matter but there's far more to a Qb then how good his team is
this is a quote from montana quote: we had the rings, marino had everything else
so rings aren't everything
recent years
ignore the fact that manning has had no offensive linemen or his star wideout but im not ignorrant enough to say he outperformed brady
personal abillities
brady is a great clutch, and tighter spiral, a tad faster
manning has a stronger arm, master of the play action, more accurate, and actually changes up the play, and is a tad bigger and stronger
bottom line it's close
but i at many other say manning won

bboobbyy wrote:

peyton wins in stats overall
well isn't Tom's 2007 better than peyton's 2004
well peyton still wins in passer rating, yards per attempt, completion, and has had less attempts in both thier magical seasons
rings matter but there's far more to a Qb then how good his team is
this is a quote from montana quote: we had the rings, marino had everything else
so rings aren't everything
recent years
ignore the fact that manning has had no offensive linemen or his star wideout but im not ignorrant enough to say he outperformed brady
personal abillities
brady is a great clutch, and tighter spiral, a tad faster
manning has a stronger arm, master of the play action, more accurate, and actually changes up the play, and is a tad bigger and stronger
bottom line it's close
but i at many other say manning won

I hear your argument, but you fail to mention some of the elements which makes Brady's cause to the argument. The list is too long to mention at this time. Thus, I think this argument is better served to be discussed on a later date when both careers are OVER and who prevails with the Numbers which will tell who ranked higher than the other. In either regard, both will go down in the Hall of Fame; and a great rivalry, for the tiem being, to say the least. Good times to be an AFC Football fan (either Indy or NE).

Time will tell as history will speak for itself over speculation.

but it depends what u think a good qb is?

do u compare side by side seasons and award a point for each season?
the accuracy and velocity of thier arm?
thier peak?
thier rings?
thier overall stat careers?

manning wins in 3 brady wins in 2

but there is a lot of extra such as how good a clutch, qb intellegence, scrambling ability, and many others

so far i think manning has won but:
if manning wins another ring and breaks all those records(which it seems like his destined to) i don't think 4 much less 3 rings can overshadow that and as for brady 5 rings or maybe even 6 u know it's over and brady's the best ever

but whoever wins this will be the best qb ever even better than bradshaw and montana

but honestly i think manning has clearly won i gave the peak to brady but i look at it and can't say brady clearly won

some say it's all about the rings well think about this: my friend made a fantasy team in madden 08 his qb was drew brees

his team was dominate but drew brees wasn't the best qb but he was close do u ever think and say that might be possible in rl

TOM BRADY BY FAR

why is tb better saying it does no good tell me why?

no contest brady is god maanning has nothing on him.if brady had the same wrs for his whole career he would be breaking records left and right like he was in his 07-08 season.

I completely agree with bboobbyy. This is about comparing the 2 QB's not the teams. Rings are won by teams, stat's are achieved by individuals. Also, Peyton has the stats without going after them. In 2004, the Colts weren't trying to run up the score throughout the season, so Sorgi, the backup QB played in 4 games had 175 yards and 2 touchdowns. Peyton only played one quarter of the last regular season game. Imagine if Peyton had played all games in their entirety that year. Might I add Sorgi had more touchdowns that year than he did this year (only 1). How many yards and touchdowns did Cassel have this year? I honestly don't remember him completing a pass and I know he didn't have a touchdown. You probably don't remember either, he was pulled almost immediately after being put in each time. Brady played almost every minute of every game. So in reality when Brady broke Manning's record it was almost an illusion. Manning has more touchdowns/minute played, and that is something no one will ever come close to. Btw, Marino's backup didn't play much and didn't have any touchdowns in '84 either, so the TD/min really would be Peyton's.

colts_fans wrote:

<quoted text>
Robert Horry has 6 NBA rings is he the best forward of all time?????
Trent dilfer has a ring is he better than Marino who has 0?

Very true and agree totally with your point, and for the guy you responded to saying he's a die-hard Colts fan, if he truly were he wouldn't down manning so flatly, and this must be an old article cause Manning did win a ring 2 years ago and according to him Manning hadn't. The fact is Brady was surrounded by a better team his whole career, Manning has been the better QB all along. Rings are a TEAM measure, not a measure of the QB. If the QB was end all be all of a team, the Bears would have never been in the 2006 SB. The team made it there in spite of Rex!

Peyton by far.