Another one for your list! St. Margaret's House Thrift Shop at 49 Fulton Street is across the street from South Street Seaport, accessible from multiple subways at the Fulton Street stop and is a comfortable and inexpensive place to find a bit of anything you are looking for. Average price is $2.00 and rarely is anything over $5. We are indoors a large housing complex complete with cafeteria, restrooms, garden. This is a small, neat and clean shop with good quality merchandise at old fashioned thrift store prices. Check it out Tues-Fri 12:00-3:00.