Tom Brady is Overrated

Full story: Dr. U

Tom Brady of the New England Patriots is the most overrated quarterback in the NFL.
Comments
1 - 20 of 10,024 Comments Last updated Thursday Jul 31
First Prev
of 502
Next Last
iberiano

Panama City, FL

#1 Jan 19, 2006
i couldnt agree with you more,im a cardinals fan so im not biased against new england,they are a great franchise and i dont feel THEY are overrated,Tom Brady however is IMO without a shadow of a doubt the most overrated football pl.....i mean athelete i have ever seen in my life.With as much time as he has in the pocket and the way their offense is run(alot of short passes that rb's and wr's turn into big plays because of great blocking)many qb's could do what brady does and probably do it better,enough with the comparisons to montana already,tom brady is nowhere near montana........just my personal opinion though

Judged:

19

14

6

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#2 Jan 24, 2006
I have been saying that for years. Brady is over rated. You could take any QB from any team even second strigers and put them on new england with the same results brady has had.

Judged:

11

10

4

Reply »
Report Abuse Judge it!
keiso21

Omaha, NE

#3 Jan 24, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
I have been saying that for years. Brady is over rated. You could take any QB from any team even second strigers and put them on new england with the same results brady has had.
ARE YOU SERIOUS? Tom Brady is the greatest football player in the NFL right now and maybe the past 20 years. Tell me what other player would you rather have under center in a 2:00 situation? Name someone playing the game right now. I think your just mad cause Tom "2 time superbowl MVP" Brady isn't the type of quarterback to make a big fuss about being the best. Tom really is picture of a great team player. He has paid his time as a back up qb to Bledsoe and took his first chance swinging and won a superbowl. If anything I think has been rated fairly.
ron

Fayetteville, NC

#4 Jan 25, 2006
If Tom Brady is overrated then so is michael vick, peyton manning just to name a few. Atleast he can win a big game in a crunch situation. So you can all stop hating now because you got what you wanted he is not going to another super bowl this and its not for lack of trying if it was not for brady the pats would not have made it as far as they did.
trev

United States

#7 Jan 30, 2006
it's real simple, take any qb you want and put them on the 2001 pats...24th ranked defense and 24th ranked running game...then put them on the 2003 pats...30th in yards per carry...how many rings do they win?
columbus wolverine

Chicago, IL

#8 Feb 1, 2006
The kid is sharp. Smart as a tack.
Does anyone remember his senior year at Michigan, "The Comeback KID" ? come on. He's got ice in his veins, cool and calm under pressure. ala Joe Montana.

You can take John Kitna, or how about Joey Harrington, they
would never make it happen on the 2001 Pats.. the very fact that they were ranked 24th in both rushing and in defense, shows you the power of what a composed leader can do for a team.
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#9 Feb 3, 2006
It is a SIN to even metion Bradys name with the likes of Joe Montana,John Elway,Jim Kelly,Dan Marino.He's not even close to being in their elite class.
LOL

Allentown, PA

#10 Feb 3, 2006
Tom Brady is already a HOFer playing right now and he's how old? Let not be so silly here people, he's rated right where he should be and that's at the top....you want to talk overrated there's some guy in Indy that needs mentioning....
Steve

United States

#11 Feb 6, 2006
I am so sick of hearing that Brady is overated. Peyton manning cant win a big game with one some of the best offensive tools in the NFL. look at that guys recivers. brady did it all in the air in 2001 and 2003. they had NOOOO running game. you cant win 3 suberbowls in 4 years and be average. like someone was saying michael vick has accomplished nothing. eli manning is a joke. all these guys who come into the league and cant get it done. then you have guys like brady who come out of the 6th round and work their asses off. Tom brady shows more leadership then any quaterback in the NFL. you could be like manning and take the 100million and crush the cap for your team. or you can be like brady and be team guy. 3 CHAMPIONSHIPS 2 SUPER BOWL MVPs WHAT DOES THIS GUY NEED TO DO TO GET SOME RESPECT. 49 touchdown passes means nothing when you cant score a point in the playoffs like manning did last year. the whole colts team scored 3. name one quaterback that is better.
jabed

New Paltz, NY

#12 Feb 7, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
I have been saying that for years. Brady is over rated. You could take any QB from any team even second strigers and put them on new england with the same results brady has had.
Ridiculous. Brady is an accurate, intelligent quarterback, who does not get flustered by the pressure of any defences. It is not as easy as it looks to be a good quarterback. West Coast offences do not all work the way Brady makes his work. Ask the Lions. Brady has a certain intangable ability and is a very tough competitor. To suggest otherwise is naive.
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#13 Feb 8, 2006
Steve, I would take Delhomme or Hasselbach over brady any day.
LOL

Allentown, PA

#14 Feb 8, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
Steve, I would take Delhomme or Hasselbach over brady any day.
Now that's funny LOL
edbert

AOL

#15 Feb 8, 2006
thats exactly what we want. you can have your mannings,burgermeisters, dehommes, hafflebacks, or anybody else. brady is staying in ne. just the way we want it
john from ny

Pittsford, NY

#16 Feb 8, 2006
keiso21 wrote:
<quoted text>
ARE YOU SERIOUS? Tom Brady is the greatest football player in the NFL right now and maybe the past 20 years. Tell me what other player would you rather have under center in a 2:00 situation? Name someone playing the game right now. I think your just mad cause Tom "2 time superbowl MVP" Brady isn't the type of quarterback to make a big fuss about being the best. Tom really is picture of a great team player. He has paid his time as a back up qb to Bledsoe and took his first chance swinging and won a superbowl. If anything I think has been rated fairly.
yeah right, tom brady sucks. its the people around him who make him look good. im pretty sure that if i had corey dillion on my team or deion branch, i'd be pretty good too. but him on a team like the texans, and then if he is any good.
LOL

Allentown, PA

#17 Feb 8, 2006
I guess it was Dillon making him look good in his first 2 SB's too....or maybe you should go compare Branch to T.O. beings he's that great too....this whole topic is a joke.
jim from buffalo

Buffalo, NY

#18 Feb 9, 2006
edbert wrote:
thats exactly what we want. you can have your mannings,burgermeisters, dehommes, hafflebacks, or anybody else. brady is staying in ne. just the way we want it
Good you can keep him there.loser
Richard

Barrington, RI

#19 Feb 10, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
I have been saying that for years. Brady is over rated. You could take any QB from any team even second strigers and put them on new england with the same results brady has had.
I would expect that from some one from Buffalo. Don't be jealous, it's ok, the Bills are bound to get another 4 chances to lose, especially with Marv back....
Richard

Barrington, RI

#20 Feb 10, 2006
trev wrote:
it's real simple, take any qb you want and put them on the 2001 pats...24th ranked defense and 24th ranked running game...then put them on the 2003 pats...30th in yards per carry...how many rings do they win?
Oh, brilliant. That's like saying, "hey, get rid of the clouds and it will stop raining. They have 3 now, without the attitude.
Richard

Barrington, RI

#21 Feb 10, 2006
jim from buffalo wrote:
Steve, I would take Delhomme or Hasselbach over brady any day.
Way to go Jim, two losers for a three time winner. You must have gone to college.
Rich New York

AOL

#22 Feb 12, 2006
Obviously the author of this post has has no clue as to what he is talking about!... Professional players in sports are rated by 2 categories during thier careers.. Personal statistics and ultimately winning championships. Tom Brady to date has not put up the best statistics amongst his QB peers ala P Manning, but he has guided the New England Patriots to 3 Championships, winning the MVP in 2 of them!... The author of this post in declaring T Brady is overrated clearly values posting hallow statistics over guiding teams to championships - like I stated earlier "He has no clue"! HERE IS ANOTHER THING FOR OUR FRIEND TO THINK OF - Tom Brady is only 28, QBs' generally get better with age, combine that with a great coach in B Belichick and the New England Patriots will return to glory sooner than later!...Last but not least Get well soon T Brady!!!(Sports Hernia) which he played with for half a year. He recently underwent surgery and will require 6 to 8 weeks of recovery!

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

First Prev
of 502
Next Last

Add your comments below

Characters left: 4000

Please note by submitting this form you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

New England Patriots Discussions

Title Updated Last By Comments
Peyton Manning is Better Than Brady, Says Talib 3 hr George 335
Tom Brady not wearing a Patriots uniform? Brace... Fri Soon 2B Fartin Fred 5
New Patriots Scratch Ticket Offers Game Trips t... Fri Soon 2B Fartin Fred 3
3-Down Linebackers Grow Scarcer Fri Soon 2B Fartin Fred 13
NFL roundup: Pats swap Mankins to Buccaneers Thu Flatulence Fred 1
Tom Brady is Impossible Thu Flatulence Fred 67
Wes Welker's Latest Concussion Validates New En... Aug 26 Flatulence Fred 7
•••
•••
Enter and win $5000
•••

New England Patriots People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••