Best NFL quarterback of all time?

Local: Los Angeles, CA (change)

Join the Topix community today:

1 2 3

At least 153 killed in Madrid plane crash

Did Phelps 'really' win his 7th gold medal?

Toby Keith throws support behind Obama

NFL Football

Comments

Showing posts 1 - 20 of 736

« prev | next »

Go to last post | Jump to page:

Yan S Green Bay, WI	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #1 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 There is no such thing as "the greatest" or "best". Each has their own unique circumstances. Their unique teammates: defense, offensive line, backs, receivers....; as well as opponent defenses of their day. Also a really great qb could play for a terrible team and forgotten. Someone mentioned Archie Manning to this respect. This is not to belittle any qb and their accomplishments. There simply is no "the best".
Bubble-Eez Green Bay, WI	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #2 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 Some people are risk-adverse and others are more risk takers. Favre, despite his INT record he has less INT per pass ave. then Elway or Aikman and is barely higher than Marino.
B1llsfan Louisville, KY	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #3 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 2 1 1 Typical dopes buying the Marino, Elway, Montana hype. Guess who beat all three to go to the Super Bowl? That's right; Jim Kelly. No, he didn't win one, but he kept pretender Marino pouting and yelling on the sidelines (and the original "Jaw," Shula, during the prime of each of their careers. If Marino's ego wasn't so big, he would have had a running attack and maybe could have beaten Kelly's Bills when it mattered most. And, whoever put No-Knees Namath on this poll is an idiot.
no one Saint Louis, MO	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #4 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 PEYTON MANNING!!!!
Robert C Glencoe, IL	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #5 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 Jim McMahon. The Punk QB.
Dissatisfied Republican “Wait till next year” Joined: Aug 13, 2007 Comments: 304 Leicester, NC ISP Location: Asheville, NC	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #6 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 The greatest is a transitory thing. Right now the greatest is Peyton Manning. I don't know what tommorrow will bring.
s bent Kissimmee, FL	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #7 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 when its all said and done, Peyton Manning will be the best qb to ever play the game if he stays healthy and continues to play as well as he has.
redzoneroy69 Joined: Sep 15, 2007 Comments: 255 North Surrey, Canada	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #8 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 2 1 1 After thid season I'm sure Tom Brady will be on the list and I think he should be right now! Man he's got three SB's and he's only 30 years old.

Stump Cleveland, OH	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #9 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 2 1 really not a fair question . In my youth Terry Bradshaw was the greatest. While in the service Joe Montana was the greatest . During my first wife it was Troy Aikmen . During my second wife it was John Elway . Now with this fine dime piece i got now who thinks i'm going to marry her its got to be Tom Brady . But if i can get with the cute redhead across the pond Peyton Manning will be the greatest .
Lindsay Grace Joined: Oct 5, 2007 Comments: 1 AOL	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #11 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 2 I lik the Steelers, for all answers.
Terri Schiavo Denver, CO	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #13 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 I vote for Kerry Collins. Nothing like checking out those 90's clips of Kerry flinging the ball down the field to Rae Carruth. If Rae hadn't been sent to the packing house, they would have won some rings. Now Rae is wearing one from his wife Frank, and Kerry is seeking a job with the NAACP. PS: My feeding tube is for sale.
Pick-n-Bones “dura lex sed lex” Joined: Sep 4, 2007 Comments: 111 MidWest USA ISP Location: Indianapolis, IN	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #14 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 Today it has to be Peyton Manning, all things can change. He owns the record books at this time and has a long career ahead if he stays healthy.
seayers Saint Louis, MO	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #15 Oct 5, 2007 No contest...Peyton Manning.
Bill Leesburg, FL	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #16 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 How can you have a list like that without having Roger Staubach on it??
Lillie Johnson City, TN	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #17 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 peyton manning!!!
Dogen3 Indianapolis, IN	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #18 Oct 5, 2007 Peyton Manning. Montana is the only other one with a serious claim.
eric Monroe, WI	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #19 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 1 1 peyton manning plays in a dome, whats his record outside in the eliments, cold, snow rain ect. With Marvin Harrison, Wayne, and the whole offense he has in this pass happy league with rules to match hsi numbers are almost average in this day and age.Favre who is ancient comeparred to alot of guys will have comperable numbers and Brady will have better numbers.
Lillie Johnson City, TN	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #20 Oct 5, 2007 Judged: 1 eric wrote: peyton manning plays in a dome, whats his record outside in the eliments, cold, snow rain ect. With Marvin Harrison, Wayne, and the whole offense he has in this pass happy league with rules to match hsi numbers are almost average in this day and age.Favre who is ancient comeparred to alot of guys will have comperable numbers and Brady will have better numbers. get over yourself. everyone knows manning is the best
Hanley Green Bay, WI	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #21 Oct 5, 2007 Babe Laufenberg
Yan S Green Bay, WI	Reply » \| Report Abuse \| Judge it! \| #22 Oct 5, 2007 Yeah, I don't even want to get into the "system" argument. I'll keep it simply as this: a great defense takes a ton of pressure off the offense to be superb and take a lot of risks. And if that team also has backs and receivers... and also an o-line which can pass protect... Regardless of what system an offense has, if there are a decent number of great players, they are going to make each other and the team that much better.

Showing posts 1 - 20 of 736

« prev | next »

Go to last post | Jump to page:

Type in your comments to post to the forum

Name
(appears on your post)

Comments

Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Other Recent NFL Football Discussions

Topic	Updated	Last By	Comments
City Series: Brothers back in backfield	6 min	Hyre	3
Patriots unfazed by 'favorites' tag (from Sep '07)	7 min	18andDONEwih...	103
Developer shuts down site work	9 min	No Name	4
AFC Rankings	10 min	Jeebs	206
Pittsburgh Stealers -- The death tax may force ...	10 min	jinx-ur-team	9
Steelers hope for improved offensive line	12 min	Facts vs Tards	12
Audible on playbook for Favre	13 min	mrmagoo67	14

Joe Montana	5646	28%
Brett Favre	4371	22%
I'll write my OWN vote in...	2281	11%
Dan Marino	1914	9%
Johnny Unitas	1472	7%
John Elway	1368	6%
Terry Bradshaw	973	4%
Troy Aikman	860	4%
Joe Namath	501	2%
Steve Young	386	1%
Current Total	19772

Best NFL quarterback of all time?

NFL Football News

Daily Horoscope for August 21

Taurus

Game Tickets

Most Popular