Judge it!So, what are you still doing reading it online for? BTW, it's sad when you have a female portraying you in a movie.(and you're a male).any movie this guy anderson likes this much has got to stink! he's BY FAR the WORST movie reviewer NEWSDAY ever had. usually he writes a political column disguised as a movie review. he supposedly took early retirement but of course still writes for NEWSDAY. just like KLURFELD who's stll writing the editorials although he retired too. pure BS. that's NEWSDAY! the MORTAL ENEMY of the home owners and tax payers of nassau county. the best thing i ever did was cancel their stinkin' paper!
'I'm Not There' -
Todd Haynes has thrown down the gauntlet with "I'm Not There," and not just because he remakes Bob Dylan from simply the poet laureate of his generation into the first living celebrity/ singer/songwriter to be ...
Comments
Showing posts
1 - 19 of19
|
|
||||
|
what has all this got to do with a bob dylan forum. could we not keep the politics for somewhere else.
|
||||
|
I'm white, and I am completely bored by Dylan...figger that.
Dylan fans get on my nerves. |
||||
|
you can't be that bored with him when you are logging in to this forum and posting comments. Methinks you are out to provoke a response. With kids we call it attention seeking
|
||||
|
love dylan. hated movie, except for
the black kid. should've followed him to hollywood. |
||||
|
Dylan fans are blinded by their orgasmic attraction. Why bother watching a bunch of people pretend to be him in a movie....it's the self-indulgent equivalent to cross-dressing.
|
||||
|
"Orgasmic Attraction" as Andrew put it, is the point. The man is a myth, and the movie is an exploration of the myth. It doesn't seek to clarify, only to point out the fog of myth. The soundtrack is an essential part of this experience; other musical kingpins from Willie Nelson to Calexico reinterpret and reinvent, which is the key to keeping a myth alive. Wonderful!
|
||||
|
Like I said, Dylan bores the shit out of me...outside of Lay Lady Lay.
And now I find out my crotchety Film Group wants to discuss this, ugh! |
||||
|
I like from Blood on the tracts on forward myself most of all.
|
||||
|
Too bad there are no gang scenes. Just a bunch of White Artists with obviously too much time on their hands.
|
||||
|
Eaton Bray, UK |
Weird film
|
|||
|
Actually.....in retrospect, I have to give the film some credit.
It was a very ambitiously creative attempt at storytelling....The Richard Gere stuff didn't work for me....but I have to give the other storylines their due.....good work. |
||||
|
Eaton Bray, UK |
Not one of my favourites
|
|||
|
As weird as the film was, this review is even weirder:
http://www.youtube.com/watch... Someone please tell me this is not for real! |
||||
Seems real to me. But, man, what a set of lungs on that chick! |
||||
|
If you've seen I'm Not There, see it again. The film is so good that it ranks as the best thing ever done about Dylan. Yes!, way better than the Scorsese thing.
Not only that, it is just a very good creative movie. As far as I'm concerned, Blanchett won the supporting role oscar. |
||||
|
Eaton Bray, UK |
I like Cate Blanchett
|
|||
|
“TCW World Heavyweight Champion” Since: May 07
ISP: Surrey, Canada |
I liked it, although the biggest criticism of it would probably be that it wasn't very much of a stand alone film. As a fan of Dylan's music myself, I understood most of what was going on throughout it, but someone who had no previous knowledge of him would likely not enjoy sitting through it. The actors almost all did a great job portraying their respective character(s) and overall it was one of the top movies of the year
|
|||
|
Eaton Bray, UK |
I prefer documentries with access to the star
|
|||
|
||||
Showing posts
1 - 19 of19
Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.
Other Recent Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid Discussions
Search the Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid Forum:
Search the Pat Garrett & Billy the Kid Forum:
| Topic | Updated | Last By | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| 10 reasons why Oscar has a tin ear (Feb '09) | Feb '09 | SPARTACUS | 13 |
| Pat Garrett and Billy the Kid (Dec '08) | Dec '08 | HeadRest | 1 |
| 'I'm Not There': All parts of the Dylan explora... (Dec '07) | Dec '07 | Jay Philips | 1 |
Related Topix Forums:
Entertainment,
African-American,
Television,
Pop/Rock,
Movies,
Western,
History Movies,
Bob Dylan,
Cate Blanchett
Daily Horoscope for January 6
Aquarius
You will need to make a very important decision today, with a potential boost to your career. Whatever decision you make today will be the correct one and lead you to the right course of action. Your health will be under pressure, perhaps a temporary respiratory problem.
|
Reach local customers. Engage a specific demographic. Maximize business-to-business opportunities. Topix can deliver your message.
|
Copyright ©2009 Topix LLC
