Potential Offseason NHL Trades I: Joe Thornton to Philadelphia

Don't see this happening any time soon. Plus I think Thorton disappears during the playoffs. which the Flyers don't need another player to do.

Red Bandit wrote:

Don't see this happening any time soon. Plus I think Thorton disappears during the playoffs. which the Flyers don't need another player to do.

I agree. This trade doesn't make sense because there's no reason a team would accept Danny Briere and Joffrey Lupul (a combined 10.75M in cap space) in exchange for Joe Thornton, and have Joe play on the third line for the Flyers, while the Sharks have little Danny Briere playing on the top line, and getting squashed by the tougher Western Conference teams. I don't see this happening. A deal that sounds more likely is Joffrey Lupul, Andreas Nodl and a pick in exchange for Pavelski and the rights to Mike Grier. That would give the Flyers a third line center with a ton of potential and a gritty third line winger that can bring a great amount of forecheck. Then the Flyers can reacquire Upshall and have a third line of Upshall-Pavelski-Grier...that would be really solid.

what about lupul nodl and a pick for setaguchi

Setogucchi would be a great addition to the Flyers and has way more upside than Lupul does, but I doubt the Sharks would be willing to part with Devin unless they got Lupul, JVR, Nodl, and a pick. I don't want JVR to be used in a trade for a forwards, too. So, Setogucchi is out of the question.

this would be the trade for thorton giroux, first rounder, briere, lupul only way it can work for both sides.

Red Wings25 wrote:

<quoted text>
I agree. This trade doesn't make sense because there's no reason a team would accept Danny Briere and Joffrey Lupul (a combined 10.75M in cap space) in exchange for Joe Thornton, and have Joe play on the third line for the Flyers, while the Sharks have little Danny Briere playing on the top line, and getting squashed by the tougher Western Conference teams. I don't see this happening. A deal that sounds more likely is Joffrey Lupul, Andreas Nodl and a pick in exchange for Pavelski and the rights to Mike Grier. That would give the Flyers a third line center with a ton of potential and a gritty third line winger that can bring a great amount of forecheck. Then the Flyers can reacquire Upshall and have a third line of Upshall-Pavelski-Grier...that would be really solid.

hahaha, you think Joe Thornton is a 3rd line center. I'm sure he'd do great playing 14 minutes a game.

Faces, i never said that i believe Thornton is a 3rd line center...he's definitely a no.1 center. I was saying that it wouldn't make sense to bring Joe Thornton since Richards and Carter are our no.1 and 2 centers, and putting a no.1 center(on the 3rd line) is stupid. The guy who wrote this article believes that Thornton would thrive playing on the third line because he wouldn't have to carry the load.

And Flyersfan12, there is no way in HELL i'd ever give up Giroux. I don't care who the Flyers would be trading for, even if it was Roberto Luongo...I would never give Claude Giroux up. In Giroux, the Flyers have a franchise right wing. Plus, Thornton also has a big cap hit, and why would the Flyers pay 7M for a guy to play on the third line, when they can just use their money to go after a guy like Radek Bonk (a faceoff specialist) to be their third line center, and get some gritty third line wingers. Giroux, Richards, Carter, and Coburn are the 4 players that are not going anywhere.

Im with you, i dont want to give up giroux. I meant thats what you would have to give up.

i dont see a point to getting thorton either.

Red Wings25 wrote:

<quoted text>
I agree. This trade doesn't make sense because there's no reason a team would accept Danny Briere and Joffrey Lupul (a combined 10.75M in cap space) in exchange for Joe Thornton, and have Joe play on the third line for the Flyers, while the Sharks have little Danny Briere playing on the top line, and getting squashed by the tougher Western Conference teams. I don't see this happening. A deal that sounds more likely is Joffrey Lupul, Andreas Nodl and a pick in exchange for Pavelski and the rights to Mike Grier. That would give the Flyers a third line center with a ton of potential and a gritty third line winger that can bring a great amount of forecheck. Then the Flyers can reacquire Upshall and have a third line of Upshall-Pavelski-Grier...that would be really solid.

Agree with every thing you said. I would like to see Upshall come back, but I think since he is a free agent he would be asking for alot of money. I think the Flyers need to be a little tight with their money and not give out the NMC or NTC like there candy.