Judged:
5
5
5
Comments
|
Judged:
5
5
5 |
|
|
Judged:
4
3
2 The article also covered adults, but I suppose you couldn't stick with it long enough. |
|
|
Judged:
7
6
5 Saying a child with adhd is just spoiled is like telling a child with a limp to just learn to walk straight. |
|
|
Judged:
2
1
1 |
|
|
Judged:
5
2
1 |
|
|
Judged:
4
1
1 I feel for you and admire your devotion to help your child. HOwever, I believe that there are some (not yours) that are simply difficult kids that the parents want an easy fix.. so medicate the child. I have a friend who is a elementary teacher who says that over half her class are on redilin (spelled incorrectly, sorry)and they have to take a "med break" every morning! That's why conferences like this are good... we need to learn to recognize what/who are the ones that really do need the meds and who needs "the swift kick" as mentioned in the posting above. |
|
|
Judged:
3
1 i agree with much of what you stated. I have a child also that has ADHD and honestly, if he had been my 1st I would have not realized that his behavior was more then "boys being boys", being that he was my 3rd I realized when he was very young that something wasn't quite right. Parent's jump on the drug bandwagon w/o trying anything else or doing their own research (the MD did not help, as I wasn't ready to medicate, they stated to "call us when you're ready for medication"-what?! he was 3 years old!) i did my own research and spent a year debating before finally resorting to medication, and why i still don't like it, my son is almost 11 years old, gets excellent marks in school and has progressed to medication on school days only, and manages his symptoms with the help of his family and other tools we have taught him over the years. ADHD is over diagnosised and too often used as an excuse for poor behavior |
|
|
“Ha ha Yeah right”
Joined: Jun 10, 2008
Comments: 157
SSP
ISP Location:
Saint Paul, MN
|
Judged:
2
1 That's because most parents are lazy and don't want to deal with their children so they take them to the Dr. and say that the child is hyper and can't comcentrate and blah blah blah. Its so sad to think about how many kids in one elementary school classroom are drugged up. Most of these kids just need parents who are more active in their lives |
|
Judged:
3
2
1 So a 'swift kick' wouldn't have done any good, and anyone who thinks so is truly ignorant, sorry. ADHD kids have trouble making friends, taking turns, sitting still, acknowledging other peoples' "personal spaces" and therefore become isolated in a lot of cases. Within a month of starting his meds, his classmates warmed up to him because he wasn't as erratic as he had been. And undiagnosed ADHD in kids can present itself as depression or anxiety disorder in adults; if we can stop that from happening, why shouldn't we try? I know there are probably thousands of kids that are medicated who shouldn't be, but those who truly need it should not be denied it because of ignorance and the stigma of being on meds. And my children (both ADHD) are not spoiled; they're polite, well-mannered, extremely bright and can carry on conversations with adults as well as their peers and are quite a joy to be around. They just needed some help to get there and it was my responsibility as a parent to do whatever needed to be done to that end. Meds are not the only answer. Both my sons know that they have as much responsibilty to monitor their behavior whether they get their meds or not. As they mature, it's easier for some to 'catch themselves' and change their behaviors, but for some it takes other methods. |
|
|
Judged:
1
1
1 I object to your statement...if you had a child with ADHD you may have more consideration. I'm sure there are some kids misdiagnosed, but that may include ADD as well as ADHD. Lazy parents probably wouldn't take their child to the doctor...Just because something is diagnosed more does not mean it it's misdiagnosed, we just hear more about it (like we do with most things in the age we live in). As a parent, it was a struggle to put my son on medication. I didn't want him to change or be "drugged" and the sense of failure as a parent is overwhelming. Thankfully, a friend who was diagnosed after high school told me how he wished he had been able to be medicated in his younger years, that school would have been so much better for him. |
|
|
Judged:
2
1
1 |
|
|
Judged:
1
1 |
|
|
Judged:
2
1
1 All in all, please parents, make sure you have your kids tested by a knowledgable specialist in ADHD and ADD and if your kids are diagnosed and medicated do not EVER blame the fact that they are "acting up" because they have not had their meds. You need to keep the medication part low-key otherwise they too will blame their behavior on no meds and come to think they don't have to take responsibility for anything. A big part of dealing with ADHD is to accept it and learn what works for you as an individual to deal with it yourself. |
|
|
“Ha ha Yeah right”
Joined: Jun 10, 2008
Comments: 157
SSP
ISP Location:
Saint Paul, MN
|
Judged:
1 How is possible that over half of the population of children are diagnosed with either ADD or ADHD. To me, that seems then that thats just how kids are. I have worked in enough daycares and elementary school classrooms to see that some of these kids who are on medication maybe just need a little extra attention. No, I am not a dr so I cant say for sure who has what and what kids need meds. But in my opinion, I see ADHD as an excuse with parents. |
|
Judged:
1
1 you make valid points in your opinions, however you cannot make a blanket statement about all ADHD cases because of some poor examples |
|
|
“Ha ha Yeah right”
Joined: Jun 10, 2008
Comments: 157
SSP
ISP Location:
Saint Paul, MN
|
Judged:
2
1
1 I never said all ADHD cases were the cause of poor parenting. I said most. And I do believe that. I doubt even half of the kids diagnosed with ADHD really have it. I feel like its just an excuse. |
|
Judged:
2
1
1 True ADD or ADHD students simply do not have the ability to concentrate or, in some cases, sit still. I agree that there are some parents who take their children to the doctor for an ADHD diagnosis in hopes that there is a quick fix. And I remember certain doctors who seemed to diagnose most children with ADHD. Let's not dismiss the disability or the treatment. I have seen dramatic results. Ex: a student who was frustrated an unable to do the simplest math problems, suddenly knew all of his multiplication facts--which were in his brain but needed the chemical connection in the brain to make it happen. I have also seen cases of no change or negative results as a result of treatment. Every child is different. If a parent came to me with a concern about his/her child being unable to learn, my advice always was to take the child to a physician that he/she trusted and tell the doctor the same thing I was told. Would you do any less for your child? By the way, my first comment was that I am adult with ADHD. I was disorganized, off task, and had a hard time concentrating--and my grades showed it. The thing that got me through high school and college was that all of the adults in my community, my parents, teachers, members of my church, etc., made me be responsible for my work and my behavior. That is part of the equation, too. |
|
|
Judged:
4
2 Q:How many ADHD kids does it take to change a lightbulb? A:Wanna ride bikes? |
|
|
Judged:
2
1 |
|
|
Judged:
2
1 |
|
Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.
| Topic | Updated | Last By | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Verifying ADHD supplements' effectiveness is st... | 1 hr | mom | 2 |
| ADHD Study: Should we wait or medicate? (from Nov '07) | 3 hr | HumanSpirit | 25 |
| Local stages turn vibrant - Features | 12 hr | Jenn | 2 |
| Majority Of Teachers 'Have Difficulty Understan... | 14 hr | HumanSpirit | 24 |
| ADHD Drugs Have No Long term Effects (from Nov '07) | 16 hr | HumanSpirit | 6 |
| Slower brain maturity seen in children with att... (from Nov '07) | Fri | HumanSpirit | 4 |
| The Naughty Column: Child runs wild | Oct 3 | rsds | 1 |