Giants' Tyree still thinks his catch is best ever

Judged:

11

8

7

belichick adoration wrote:

<quoted text>
...giants proved themselves to be what everyone had suspected after eeking out a miracle win in last year's sb... a fluke...

Judged:

9

7

5

threemoney21 wrote:

I dont think you can touch Tyree's catch. At least not with Holmes catch anyway. Granted, it was a nice catch, toe tap, and he scored the winning touchdown. But you got to understand what was on the line on the one particular play. First off, after that play the Steelers had more downs. They could have possibly scored a TD on another down. The Giants were on 4th and whatever. Ben stayed pretty still and didnt have to move much. Eli got grabbed and wheeled out of a crowd. Tyree caught the junk on his head, HIS HEAD!!! With Harrison all over him. Holmes caught it in his hands with no contact. Again, i am not taking anything away from Holmes catch. But to put it in the same category....or HIGHER is crazy. Just crazy.

Judged:

12

7

5

giants are subpar wrote:

<quoted text>
apparently this guy has got something on his mind...sounds a little jealous of Patriot dominance as well...

Judged:

9

4

2

Patriots Dynasty wrote:

<quoted text>
your inferiority complex is fully justified...

Judged:

10

6

6

skidrow wilson wrote:

<quoted text>
Look, make no mistake…I understand there is a very fine line between being Frank and being ****…I can’t resist taking the low hanging fruit here but this gal is as useless as rubber lips on a woodpecker...

Judged:

11

10

9

belichick adoration wrote:

<quoted text>
...giants proved themselves to be what everyone had suspected after eeking out a miracle win in last year's sb... a fluke...

Judged:

1

1

1

Hes-my-Quarterback wrote:

If it had been me, there would be no question about it's validity. But since it was David, he gets no love whatsoever, and all the sour grapes New England fans call it miraculous. Nonetheless, it was the play of the game and the Giants triumphed over the HEAVILY favored Patriots. It was one of the best Superbowls of all time, regardless of what Goodell said at the end of the last one.

Judged:

1

1

1

Back2Back wrote:

<quoted text>
How did that New York Headline read?
"From Champs to Chumps...ELI--MINATED!"
:D

Judged:

1

1

1

Back2Back wrote:

<quoted text>
How did that New York Headline read?
"From Champs to Chumps...ELI--MINATED!"
:D

Judged:

4

4

3

Hes-my-Quarterback wrote:

<quoted text>
Hey, what you're saying may be true and all, but it might have been a different story had it not been for the nice work on the part of Plaxico Burress. Talk about distractions.

Judged:

4

4

4

Stupid Jerry Jones wrote:

<quoted text>
18-1, thats as bad as my Cowboys be'in that thar #1 seed and choking.

Judged:

1

1

1

Back2Back wrote:

<quoted text>
I believe that falls under the "Coulda, Woulda, Should" category Mr. Team . Obliterator.

Judged:

6

4

2

SteelerFan wrote:

Tyree's catch, even though it's the only significant thing to come out of his career (4 catches that whole season), was better than Holmes' catch, considering the circumstances. Both catches were phenomenal though.