Tom Brady vs. Peyton Manning: Who's the Best? - Part II

Before you go jumping I know Manning has won a ring but he needs to match what Brady has done. Thats what I mean by he has not yet accomplished this.

dude peyton is by far the better qb...do u see tom brady with 5 straight 300+ yard games...no

Brady Gets Raddled When The Defense Starts Getting To Him...As Was Evedent In The Game With The Broncos....I Like Peyton....But Wouldnt Consider Him The Best !

tyler wrote:

dude peyton is by far the better qb...do u see tom brady with 5 straight 300+ yard games...no

Do you see Manning with three SB rings, NO.

Tom Brady is the best

I Disagree...

Tom brady is a better quarter back. Tell me peytons better when he throws 5 td passes in one quarter. Or fifty in a season

Tom Brady is by far a tougher QB mentally than Peyton Manning is. Manning is a good stats QB who is better than most at reading defenses and is accurate as hell. The problem with Manning is that the conditions need to be perfect for him to perform. He can't scramble, and when he gets hit, he gets rattled and knocked off of his game. Brady can play in any condition and always raises the level of his play as the games get bigger and more important. Peyton is not a good clutch QB in the playoffs.

Annonymous wrote:

Tom Brady is by far a tougher QB mentally than Peyton Manning is. Manning is a good stats QB who is better than most at reading defenses and is accurate as hell. The problem with Manning is that the conditions need to be perfect for him to perform. He can't scramble, and when he gets hit, he gets rattled and knocked off of his game. Brady can play in any condition and always raises the level of his play as the games get bigger and more important. Peyton is not a good clutch QB in the playoffs.

Right on.

3 rings and 2 SB mvps. enough said, Brady has my vote

lol brady throws 300 yd+ games everyweek

i think peyton manning is better by far because he has better stats and he has the ability to find the reciever better than tom and he is the best quarterback in 2009-2010 and they are going to the superbowl and they are going to win and he has a 14-0 record so that proves that peyton is far better than tom!!!!!!!!!!