|
code person
Fairfax, VA
|
Personally, my union experience is limited to white collar unions (which I think are pretty much worthless)... having said that, I grew up in a mining town ..(Steel workers union not mine workers union.. interesting).. and watched the union tear the town apart during a strike... to the point of them scaring those of us going to driver education silly... There is no doubt that unions created the middle class with better benefits and working hours... HOWEVER... blind dedication to the "union cause" is not helpful to the economy in many states (including Michigan)... I didn't move to a right to work state by choice.. it was necessity.. but is working out just fine.
|
|
confused
Fairfax, VA
|
Judged:
2
Lucy in Rockford wrote: Here's what I don't get: Union workers get cost of living raises no matter what. Non-union workers do not, and you better not ask for one. Union workers are guaranteed benefits paid entirely by the employer, and built into the cost of the product and passed onto the customer. Non-union workers have to contribute a portion of their pay for benefits. Union workers are not held accountable for their inferior work and poor work ethic. Non-union workers are summarily dismissed if they fail to adhere to company standards or speak their mind if they disagree with company policies and procedures. These are just a few reasons why unions are no longer held in high regard by the general, working public who are at will employees. This post is joint effort by Lucy and Linus. Unions have done as much to drive up the cost of merchandise as the oil speculators who drive up the price per barrel of oil. This is obviously a bone of contention with us. One more thing...you may be bombarded with answers justifying strikes because a CEO makes $$$ or because the company makes $$$ profit. Nothing, nothing to do with performance, education, pride, self esteem, personal goals, stuff I deal with every Review I've had for 20+ years...ever since I broke myself from the "union" mentality...that secure union umbrella...the one that protects those "poor work ethic" employees. I live near and work in DC and your words are more prophetic than you may realize. Check out www.wuas9.com . Look into the articles regarding education and DC trying to fire known worthless teachers...they can't...why??..because they are protected by a union...how sad because the only ones that lose are the children. Thank You for your intellegent insight and I agree with you...
|
|
confused
Fairfax, VA
|
Judged:
2
dragon_fly121 aka steve wrote: Confused....I'm on your side brother...why argue with the pro-union sheeple? You'll never win, and you just end up beating your head against the wall. Just sit back and watch them whip themselves out....it's only a matter of time. Yep...you are right...Thanks for your support. I've got so many lumps now... Have a good day!!!
|
|
Since: Mar 08
Three Rivers, MI
|
Please wait...
Judged:
2
1
Lucy, we do get 'cost of living' based on the 'Consumer price index', there have been times when we get no COLA and there have been times when our wages have decreased because COLA went down, Yes , we have healthcare, and a portion of our COLA IS DIVERTED TO HELP PAY FOR THIS HEALTHCARE. If workers are not held accountable for quality problems it is because the bosses are too lazy to do their job. I have seen people fired from our plant for poor quality, poor attendance, etc. IT SOUNDS TO ME LIKE YOU NEED TO CHECK YOUR SOURCES BEFORE YOU START SAYING THINGS YOU KNOW NOTHING ABOUT, SO I'M THINKING YOU HAVE HAD ONE TOO MANY HAPPY HOURS.. ALSO , I think you are not so much at 'at will' employee I think you are an 'ill will' employee, right in your posting you are stating yourself what the UNION IS ALL ABOUT COMPARED TO NON-UNION ,SOLIDARITY
|
|
Since: Jun 07
Location hidden
|
Please wait...
Judged:
1
Lucy in Rockford wrote: Here's what I don't get: Union workers get cost of living raises no matter what. Non-union workers do not, and you better not ask for one. Union workers are guaranteed benefits paid entirely by the employer, and built into the cost of the product and passed onto the customer. Non-union workers have to contribute a portion of their pay for benefits. Union workers are not held accountable for their inferior work and poor work ethic. Non-union workers are summarily dismissed if they fail to adhere to company standards or speak their mind if they disagree with company policies and procedures. These are just a few reasons why unions are no longer held in high regard by the general, working public who are at will employees. This post is joint effort by Lucy and Linus. Unions have done as much to drive up the cost of merchandise as the oil speculators who drive up the price per barrel of oil. This is obviously a bone of contention with us. I'm afraid you have some misconceptions about unions. It is not true that union workers get cost of living raises "no matter what." Union workers negotiate a contract, and that contract may include pay increases OR pay decreases (concessions) or no monetary change at all. It depends on what is agreed upon. Durind economic bad times union workers have decided to forego any pay increases in order to help keep a company afloat. It is simply untrue that union workers get medical benefits paid for completely by the employer. As more and more contracts come and go, workers have steadily had to increase their contributions. They agree to this in the contracts because they understand that employers cannot bear the whole burden themselves, and it doesn't do anyone any good to bankrupt the company. It is also untrue that union workers are not held accountable for inferior work. Union workers can be fired for cause. You are completely correct that "at-will" employees can be summarily fired for merely speaking their minds. This is unfair and wrong. Union workers do protect themselves from this type of treatment with the terms of their contract. Union workers can be fired for just cause (drugs, theft, attendance, incompetence, fighting, etc.) but they cannot be fired for opinions.
|
|
DARK HELMET LIVES
Cincinnati, OH
|
Arctic49519 wrote: <quoted text> That's kinda funny. Your employer makes the decision as to how much your work is worth and you make the decision to just blindly accept it without question. Really sounds like you make a lot of the decisions there. What you fail to understand is that some people have the backbone to stand up for themselves when they are getting a raw deal. While you say "yassuh, massah" to your boss, these people are fighting for what they believe is right. No one can make them work for a measly $12/hr if they don't want to. They are exercising their right to withhold their labor. American Axle is free to replace them or to negotiate with them, it's their choice. There is nothing you or any of the other anti-union whiners can do about it, so you just need to get over it. Well ... So much for decorum and being polite. I'm with Confused--and I already tagged your little racist itrade as offensive/inappropriate. In another time and place, I might just have agreed with you. But when all you can do is make personal attacks on those who disagree with you, then you make it impossible for anyone to even WANT to agree with you!
|
|
confused
Fairfax, VA
|
DARK HELMET LIVES wrote: <quoted text> Well ... So much for decorum and being polite. I'm with Confused--and I already tagged your little racist itrade as offensive/inappropriate. In another time and place, I might just have agreed with you. But when all you can do is make personal attacks on those who disagree with you, then you make it impossible for anyone to even WANT to agree with you! Thanks Dark Helmet...one thing he doesn't realize is that my boss does not determine how much my job is worth...the economy and market demand and several other factors do. If I don't like how much I'm being paid I can go somewhere else...but because I'm good at what I do, my boss gets requests for me by name, and many more factors, I don't need to look elsewhere because I'm being paid and honest wage. It's not based on a blanket contract that says I'll get it just because...it's based on my merits and my professional services provided. If you look back...and I assume you have...through the past posts, I have tried to be polite but direct about making my points. I don't need to insult someone to get my point across. I find frequently though that when you've out debated some people, their first instinct is to lash back with attempts at insults, cursing, and outlandish comments. Debate is not about trying to intimidate or belittle someone. It's supposed to be intelligent people exchanging different points of view, hoping to come to some sort of middle ground. That's not what we encounter here. Also...I realize that you meant tirade, not itrade and that typo errors happen. I could comment more on the racist thing but I'm not going to go there. His comment speaks for itself.
|
|
Mark
Grand Rapids, MI
|
Confused wrote: <quoted text> What you just don't seem to get is you, by your own argument, are giving businesses another reason to consider leaving Michigan. Apparently you have forgotten, or weren't around when General Electric pulled out of Holland over 20 years ago...BEFORE Mexico, BEFORE NAFDA...Why??? Because the union demands were too much...they didn't move to Mexico, they just moved Sout...but out of Michigan. That having been said...you just keep on believing that fighting for and demanding higher wages is going to somehow help Michigan and keep businesses in Michigan. Sheeesh... One last thing...I'm sick and tired of hearing about what union people think they deserve. All based on what the last contract says they deserve...not based on performance, education, skills. READ THIS VERY CAREFULLY...I am in no way jealous of you or your over sized paycheck. Since I got away from union involvement I have now the incentive to learn, not sit on my lazy A** and wait for my next "cost of living" raise. I take great pride in what I've accomplished and the when I'm up for review, I can honestly say I've EARNED it. I've educated myself and I LOVE what I do...I consider it playing every day and I get paid for it. You have no basis for your argument. My parents were staunch union members for years. I've heard all the arguments, all the reasons, all the justifications before. Nothing you present to me is new. This pattern repeats itself over and over. That's why 20+ years ago General Electric left Holland and today it's ??? The horrifying and sad truth is that as long as you remain within that realm of mis-conception...you lose, I lose and the other workers lose...everyone. You just keep up thinking like you are...you won't have to worry about who makes more for long unfortunately...you and a whole lot of Michigan workers will all be out of work and the Mexican workers will be thanking you...they will be making more than you because you won't have a job. I'm done typing now... You're so silly. Making sense and all that good stuff. Nice post.
|
|
|
Mark
Grand Rapids, MI
|
Arctic49519 wrote: These anti-union whiners have a very simple philosophy for union workers: Take any cuts an employer makes, no matter how unfair they are, lose your home and everything you have worked for. Do not question your employer, even when they are stuffing tens of millions into their pocket and turning a profit, because other people are jealous of you and would love to have your job. DO you have a retirement plan through your employer? How about any mutual funds? How about any other investments?
|
|
code person
Fairfax, VA
|
I COULD say this is a good reason to join a union..
Personally, I'm happy and secure in my position in a right to work state... why? because I have continued with my professional credentials to the point that I don't need the protection of a union..
I work really hard to maintain those credentials.. and I deal with union folks every day.. yes, they are hard working construction workers, who do have fall back protection... and yet, I and my team continue to educate them on why what they've been doing for 20 or 30 years doesn't meet the requirements of the Code... and they accept my input... because I am right.
Union or non-union shouldn't be the arguement as much as it should be do the job you are paid to do.. to the best of your ability.. and never quit learning... factory jobs may not go on forever..
|
|
Tell me when this thread is updated:
(Registration is not required)
Add to my Tracker
Send me an email
|