60 years later, gang leader's slaying still unsolved

Oct 23, 2007 | Posted by: roboblogger | Full story: Journal Star

“Shelton, 60 (actually, he was 59), was blasted out of a Jeep by machine-gun slugs fired by the gunmen from a black Sedan on a country road near his rich farmlands”

Few Peorians likely recognize the once-infamous name. Even fewer recall the swift and violent end of Carl Shelton as he traveled near Fairfield. via Journal Star

Comments
1,101 - 1,120 of 1,179 Comments Last updated Jun 28, 2014
big phil

Mount Carmel, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1177
Jul 13, 2012
 
The fire is still out...........looks like
James bond

Sumner, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1178
Jul 28, 2012
 
what happened?? did someone F -- t
SI Lady

Paducah, KY

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1179
Aug 10, 2012
 
Beth wrote:
<quoted text>. Can anyone tell me anything about Lula. I just found out she was my great grand mother.
Go to Find a Grave on the Internet and do a serch for LuLa Pennington who died in Florida
James bond

Olney, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1180
Aug 12, 2012
 
Agnes Fontroy Gaither Shelton (wife of Ben Marsh Shelton) obituary 1957

Mrs. Agnes Shelton dies in Florida
Well known Merriam resident died at her home Saturday; funeral was Monday (1957) Mrs. Agnes, wel known former Merriam resident and mother of the notorious Shelton Brothers died Saturday at her home, 1386 Dakar Street in Jacksonville Florida. Funeral services were conducted from the Memorial Chapel of Seas Funeral Parlors in that city, with Rev. Carl Howell, pastor of the Murray Hill Baptist Church officiating. Burial was in the Oak Lawn Cemetery. She was born in Nebo, Ky and had lived in Jacksonville
about six years. From Nebo, Ky Mrs. Shelton moved from her home to Merriam Crossroads in July 1951. She was preceded in death by her husband Ben, three sons, Carl in 1947, Bernie in 1948, and Roy in 1950, Surviving are two sons, Earl and Dalta Shelton and two daughters, Mrs Hazel McDonald and Mrs. Lulu Pennington all of Jacksonville, six grandchildren and seven great grandchildren. LULU.......LULU........NOT Lula
margie wilson

Edwardsville, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1181
Aug 13, 2012
 
James bond wrote:
Agnes Fontroy Gaither Shelton (wife of Ben Marsh Shelton) obituary 1957
Mrs. Agnes Shelton dies in Florida
Well known Merriam resident died at her home Saturday; funeral was Monday (1957) Mrs. Agnes, wel known former Merriam resident and mother of the notorious Shelton Brothers died Saturday at her home, 1386 Dakar Street in Jacksonville Florida. Funeral services were conducted from the Memorial Chapel of Seas Funeral Parlors in that city, with Rev. Carl Howell, pastor of the Murray Hill Baptist Church officiating. Burial was in the Oak Lawn Cemetery. She was born in Nebo, Ky and had lived in Jacksonville
about six years. From Nebo, Ky Mrs. Shelton moved from her home to Merriam Crossroads in July 1951. She was preceded in death by her husband Ben, three sons, Carl in 1947, Bernie in 1948, and Roy in 1950, Surviving are two sons, Earl and Dalta Shelton and two daughters, Mrs Hazel McDonald and Mrs. Lulu Pennington all of Jacksonville, six grandchildren and seven great grandchildren. LULU.......LULU........NOT Lula
LULU or LULA....I'm afraid Anna will tell you different. Ask her for the correct spelling.
Anonymous

Olney, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1182
Oct 7, 2012
 
yes
Anna

Phoenix, AZ

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1183
Oct 9, 2012
 
The problem with this is that it was written in Jacksonville, not southern Illinois. The cemetery listed can find no record of -- whom I believe to be Lula [but which I asked them to cross check]-- so I cannot obtain a picture of her grave, which would remove all doubt, although I did offer to pay for one. Thus, I'm not sure she is actually buried there. I hope that someone will shoot it for me. In the meantime I've cross checked every record, including federal databases, and there are as yet no conclusive findings. In southern Illinois, the records concerning her actual name are not readily available -- it's shown both ways.

I will find it, though.
Anna

Phoenix, AZ

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1184
Oct 9, 2012
 
I do want to add here -- for the sake of clarification -- that in the ABSENCE of OFFICIAL records in the name of LULU, it appears that my conclusions are correct and that Lula Shelton Pennington is, indeed, Lula and not Lulu.

The actual record does not bear out the additional 'facts' as provided in that Florida obituary. It seems their dates are a bit off, and I think the cemetery 'of record' is not her actual resting place.
haha

AOL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1185
Oct 9, 2012
 
cool story -
small towns are not a dull as many out sliders think ,..
.i wonder if the authorities ever found those body's that are supposed to be buried under some ones old family farms ' out house '?
since all the perpetrators are now long gone ,... its OK to tell the real story now
-were they all moon shiners & gangsters ?

or just 'petty' criminals'
and mean old hard assed hillbilly's ?
margie wilson

Glen Carbon, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1186
Oct 9, 2012
 
Anna wrote:
I do want to add here -- for the sake of clarification -- that in the ABSENCE of OFFICIAL records in the name of LULU, it appears that my conclusions are correct and that Lula Shelton Pennington is, indeed, Lula and not Lulu.
The actual record does not bear out the additional 'facts' as provided in that Florida obituary. It seems their dates are a bit off, and I think the cemetery 'of record' is not her actual resting place.
I read somewhere that her real name was "LuluBell"
Belchrest

Gainesville, FL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1187
Oct 10, 2012
 
What ever happened to Ray Walker?
Anna

United States

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1188
Oct 10, 2012
 
Belchrest wrote:
What ever happened to Ray Walker?
I would like to respond to all three of these comments as they are actually related... Lulubell isn't really believable because there's no history of these people naming their children 'childish" names. That's not meant to be taken as an opinion -- I'm merely saying that I can find no record of them saddling any child with a 'regional sounding' name they would be embarassed to carry into adulthood.

As for their position: Most called them 'Mr. Shelton' or 'Sir.' The Shelton brothers' 3 man operation was netting $13 million per year in 1928: thus, they weren't ignorant, lazy or unable to earn a living. They backed down Al Capone, remember, so to consider them 'hicks' and 'hillbillies' or even 'foolhardy' would hardly seem accurate phrases and I've never heard anyone describe them in those terms. Carl's funeral was attended by [on record] an estimated 3,000 people. He was quite popular, actually, for 'being a 'fixer' of problems. Had they not been targeted as they were, they might well have gone into politics. Others in their position did so quite successfully.

Bootleggers? Yes, certainly. And one Mr. Joseph Kennedy [father of JFK] got his start at the same time in the same game.

Finally, it is my humble opinionI that Ray Walker was in on -- if not killing him directly, then allowing Carl to be killed. Motive? Money. Upon each of their deaths, their personal wealth immediately disappeared. No one ever said family members were trustworthy -- and not all of them were.

They took care of their own. When Lulu [or Lula, depending on what you're using as a reference] and Guy Pennington were assailed and suffered numerous gunshot wounds, the Penningtons said it was Charlie Harris. Guy's brother, however, killed a man that same afternoon with a gunshot to the mouth. With Guy and Lulu/Lula immediately leaving the area upon release from a medical facility, there was no one left in the region to testify and the ambush was considered a closed case.

From an historical perspective, it's a fascinating period.
margie wilson

Glen Carbon, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1189
Oct 11, 2012
 
Anna wrote:
<quoted text>
I would like to respond to all three of these comments as they are actually related... Lulubell isn't really believable because there's no history of these people naming their children 'childish" names. That's not meant to be taken as an opinion -- I'm merely saying that I can find no record of them saddling any child with a 'regional sounding' name they would be embarassed to carry into adulthood.
As for their position: Most called them 'Mr. Shelton' or 'Sir.' The Shelton brothers' 3 man operation was netting $13 million per year in 1928: thus, they weren't ignorant, lazy or unable to earn a living. They backed down Al Capone, remember, so to consider them 'hicks' and 'hillbillies' or even 'foolhardy' would hardly seem accurate phrases and I've never heard anyone describe them in those terms. Carl's funeral was attended by [on record] an estimated 3,000 people. He was quite popular, actually, for 'being a 'fixer' of problems. Had they not been targeted as they were, they might well have gone into politics. Others in their position did so quite successfully.
Bootleggers? Yes, certainly. And one Mr. Joseph Kennedy [father of JFK] got his start at the same time in the same game.
Finally, it is my humble opinionI that Ray Walker was in on -- if not killing him directly, then allowing Carl to be killed. Motive? Money. Upon each of their deaths, their personal wealth immediately disappeared. No one ever said family members were trustworthy -- and not all of them were.
They took care of their own. When Lulu [or Lula, depending on what you're using as a reference] and Guy Pennington were assailed and suffered numerous gunshot wounds, the Penningtons said it was Charlie Harris. Guy's brother, however, killed a man that same afternoon with a gunshot to the mouth. With Guy and Lulu/Lula immediately leaving the area upon release from a medical facility, there was no one left in the region to testify and the ambush was considered a closed case.
From an historical perspective, it's a fascinating period.
So what happened to Ray Walker? That question was not answered.
Anna

Oceanside, CA

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1190
Oct 13, 2012
 
I have no idea. Walker's life was not followed after the murder of Carl Shelton. Whilel others share my suspicions, he was not charged nor prosecuted.
Anna

Oceanside, CA

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1191
Oct 13, 2012
 
Beth wrote:
<quoted text>. Can anyone tell me anything about Lula. I just found out she was my great grand mother.
I'm sorry I didn't see your post until now. You can write me off list: anna.marshand@rocketmail.com
Belchrest

Gainesville, FL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1192
Oct 13, 2012
 
I have tried to find Ray Walker or what happened to him and it is like he fell off the earth. I did hear one time he may have died in a hotel room in Peoria in the 60's or 70's. Also does anyone remember a 60-61 light blue almost white Ford Galaxy that any of the Shelton's or associates may have had after they moved to FL? Thank's for any info anyone can give.
margie wilson

Glen Carbon, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1193
Oct 14, 2012
 
Anna wrote:
<quoted text>
I would like to respond to all three of these comments as they are actually related... Lulubell isn't really believable because there's no history of these people naming their children 'childish" names. That's not meant to be taken as an opinion -- I'm merely saying that I can find no record of them saddling any child with a 'regional sounding' name they would be embarassed to carry into adulthood.
As for their position: Most called them 'Mr. Shelton' or 'Sir.' The Shelton brothers' 3 man operation was netting $13 million per year in 1928: thus, they weren't ignorant, lazy or unable to earn a living. They backed down Al Capone, remember, so to consider them 'hicks' and 'hillbillies' or even 'foolhardy' would hardly seem accurate phrases and I've never heard anyone describe them in those terms. Carl's funeral was attended by [on record] an estimated 3,000 people. He was quite popular, actually, for 'being a 'fixer' of problems. Had they not been targeted as they were, they might well have gone into politics. Others in their position did so quite successfully.
Bootleggers? Yes, certainly. And one Mr. Joseph Kennedy [father of JFK] got his start at the same time in the same game.
Finally, it is my humble opinionI that Ray Walker was in on -- if not killing him directly, then allowing Carl to be killed. Motive? Money. Upon each of their deaths, their personal wealth immediately disappeared. No one ever said family members were trustworthy -- and not all of them were.
They took care of their own. When Lulu [or Lula, depending on what you're using as a reference] and Guy Pennington were assailed and suffered numerous gunshot wounds, the Penningtons said it was Charlie Harris. Guy's brother, however, killed a man that same afternoon with a gunshot to the mouth. With Guy and Lulu/Lula immediately leaving the area upon release from a medical facility, there was no one left in the region to testify and the ambush was considered a closed case.
From an historical perspective, it's a fascinating period.
Anna,you said you thought Ray Walker might have been in on killing Carl. Do you believe little Earl may have been in on it also?
Anna

Riverside, CA

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1194
Oct 15, 2012
 
How likely is it, really, that Carl's 'bodyguards' would be unarmed? That was the story they gave officials after Carl's death, which they withessed.
Belchrest

Gainesville, FL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1195
Oct 16, 2012
 
Anna I agree with you. Those bodyguards should NEVER have gone anywhere unarmed-- I doubt if they did. To have taken Carl to his brothers to pick up the jeep and then be behind sure does not sound right. But once again--does ANYONE have any information on Ray Walker? Did he have any family--girlfriend--ect? Also still looking for that white/or very light blue Ford Galaxy. Thanks
Anonymous

Olney, IL

|
Report Abuse
|
Judge it!
|
#1196
Oct 16, 2012
 
Ray walker went up to peoria and dated or lived with one of Bernies Gal friends, and attempted to run Bernies Scames, and was quickly found to not be found. as far as was he in on Carl's murder? if he was, so was lil Earl, My opinion.......... Ray was either killed and not to be found after he went to peoria, or..... he was a disapearing Expert.........Lil Earl and Ray....after Carl came back to Fairfield, was Jobless ,so How Desperate was the 2?????? Did Carl give them a couple of MIL. to tide the over.DUHHHHH .Desperate people do desperate things

Tell me when this thread is updated: (Registration is not required)

Add to my Tracker Send me an email

Type in your comments below
Name
(appears on your post)
Comments
Characters left: 4000
Type the numbers you see in the image on the right:

Please note by clicking on "Post Comment" you acknowledge that you have read the Terms of Service and the comment you are posting is in compliance with such terms. Be polite. Inappropriate posts may be removed by the moderator. Send us your feedback.

Other Recent Morton Discussions

Search the Morton Forum:
Title Updated Last By Comments
IL Ill. House Approves Legalizing Same-Sex Civil U... (Dec '10) 39 min Terry rigsby 49,008
IL Illinois Governor Recall Amendment (Oct '10) 5 hr newpoly 1,867
IL Who do you support for Governor in Illinois in ... (Oct '10) 5 hr nono 3,842
IL Who do you support for Secretary of State in Il... (Oct '10) Jul 27 Chicagobunny 526
IL Who do you support for Attorney General in Illi... (Oct '10) Jul 16 rdarbin 641
Rufus Walker family - Cass Street (Aug '08) Jul 15 Guest 5
Rick Peck Jul 10 looking 1
•••
•••
•••
Morton Dating

more search filters

less search filters

•••

Morton Jobs

•••
Enter and win $5000
•••
•••

Morton People Search

Addresses and phone numbers for FREE

•••

Morton News, Events & Info

Click for news, events and info in Morton
•••

Personal Finance

Mortgages [ See current mortgage rates ]
•••