St. Marys Doctor Arrested on Murder Charges

Being aware of some of the evidence had by both teh Prosecution and Defense, and being familiar with both the medical and legal fields, I have this to say. The PROSECUTION has alot of work to do if they expect to win an acquittal in Camden County. Things about Jamie will come out, especially regarding his medical history and his knowledge of illicit drugs and his knowledge of the effects of mixing certain drugs with eachother that could be very detrimental to the Prosecution. Another problem I see is the Prosecutions "rush" to trial. Normally when Prosecutors go to trial so quickly, it means they have little evidence and they want to cut of the Defense's chances of gaining exculpatory evidence for their client. The indictment of Dr. Chua doesn't allege that he physically killed Mr. Carter, eitehr. The Drug Charges are what leads to the Felony Murder charge. The drug charges (writing a prescription for a non-medical purpose) are the felony that is a prerequisite for Felony Murder. It simply means that Jamie Carter died while Dr. Chua committed a felony, not that Dr. Chua physically killed Mr. Carter. It is my understanding that there was a hearing last week to have the orginal trial judge recused (she recused herself from the bond hearing) and the defense asked that another judge be appointed to hear the trial. Which I understand will in fact be in Camden County, not Glynn County which also works in the defense's favor].[/I'm not sure you know as much as you claim to know! If your such a sharp legal eagle you would know that the DA will be seeking a conviction not an acquittal. Also, the only way you would be privy to evidence both sides have is if you are actually apart of the legal teams and/or involved with the investigation; which in that case, you should be fired, disbarred etc for gossiping about issues in an on-going investigation. Also, regarding the rush to trial...I thought that was done to accommodate the Defense. If Dr. Chua is innocent why would you want him to stay in jail one day longer than absolutely necessary? You are right about one thing. The trial will be held in Camden. Just like the Grand Jury that moved to indict was from Camden. Once both sides presents their case we will have to trust the folks from Camden County to weigh the evidence and decide guilt or innocence. That is something that should not be done on a chat board.I hope your self touted medical knowledge is more extensive than your legal knowledge!QUOTE]

TO;Dr.noel chua,you have been my friend and family doctor for 5 years now and I fully support you and your family in this matter of the death of your student named jamie who overdosed on his medications.You and I know no one forced him to take all the pills and commit suicide with his own life.I have known Dr.Noel Chua for 5 years and trust him with my life with my medical care and as avery close friend and family doctor.He and his family shouldnot be held for someones elses stupidity of the death jamie.In this cruel world outhere in the human society life is cruel enough without an innocent person be held responsible for someone elses death or suicdal thoughts or those peoples actions and matter of their minds how their minds functioning in their own bodies.Dr.Chua has my personal support as a friend and family doctor as well.Dr.Chua when you get cleared of these redictuless ,stupid up charges i would put my life in your hands for medical care and advise anytime or any place in the world for me and my family! mabuhai SA Philippinas and salamat Po.Sal Luhat for my Filipino close friend and family doctor to me here in my life.You have my many thoughts and prayers concerned in this matter and my prayers go out to you and your lovely families here in the United states of America and our homeland of the republic o f the Philipines our native homeland and of the native soil we were born in our lives of our Filipino proud parents and family circles.Good Luck Dr.Chua with the American kangaroo court systems here in this world of the United States so called freedom and rights and equal justice for all concerned!
Very Respectifully Your friend,Mr.John M. Kleiber jr a native filipino himself.

legaleagle wrote:

Being aware of some of the evidence had by both teh Prosecution and Defense, and being familiar with both the medical and legal fields, I have this to say. The PROSECUTION has alot of work to do if they expect to win an acquittal in Camden County. Things about Jamie will come out, especially regarding his medical history and his knowledge of illicit drugs and his knowledge of the effects of mixing certain drugs with eachother that could be very detrimental to the Prosecution. Another problem I see is the Prosecutions "rush" to trial. Normally when Prosecutors go to trial so quickly, it means they have little evidence and they want to cut of the Defense's chances of gaining exculpatory evidence for their client. The indictment of Dr. Chua doesn't allege that he physically killed Mr. Carter, eitehr. The Drug Charges are what leads to the Felony Murder charge. The drug charges (writing a prescription for a non-medical purpose) are the felony that is a prerequisite for Felony Murder. It simply means that Jamie Carter died while Dr. Chua committed a felony, not that Dr. Chua physically killed Mr. Carter. It is my understanding that there was a hearing last week to have the orginal trial judge recused (she recused herself from the bond hearing) and the defense asked that another judge be appointed to hear the trial. Which I understand will in fact be in Camden County, not Glynn County which also works in the defense's favor.

YOU are familiar with both the medical and legal fields? Let me guess, you have extensive background watching CSI? You sound more like a cheerleader that doesn't know which team you're cheering for - just rest your case "legal eagle"..... and leave the medical and legal issues up to the professionals.

You guys can argue all you want about the legal and medical details of this case but it won't make a difference because this is a racially motivated charge and the law does not prevail when it concerns minorities. Tangina mo Jamie!!!

concerned wrote:

<quoted text>
Well, Jamie was my cousin, was also soft-spoken and mild-mannered, and this little freak of a doctor killed him.

WELL WELL WELL, dont you ever call him a little freak doctor my brother..he was such a good person,he's my sisters friend when they are in college.he's always there to help and always shares his knowledge to his co-medicine students and my sister was one of them.ive known him since i was small.He's also a God fearing person so dont judge him!!!!!!!lets just wait for the result of the case.So You AMERICANS STOP THE RACIAL DISCRIMINATION!!!!Eventhough they froze all his assets were conducting a fund raising to help on the Attorney's fee.Im from the Philippines.

Don't worry, guys. Where the doctor is, he has a lot of supporters. And they are the grateful Americans who recognize the great service he has done for the community and are looking forward to him being of service to them again.

Spectator wrote:

Don't worry, guys. Where the doctor is, he has a lot of supporters. And they are the grateful Americans who recognize the great service he has done for the community and are looking forward to him being of service to them again.

I hope that they are willing to travel to the Phillipines for their care... that is the only place he is likely to practice again.

LDodd wrote:

<quoted text>
I hope that they are willing to travel to the Phillipines for their care... that is the only place he is likely to practice again.

Philippines. one L. 2 Ps

plus one more P for the first letter hehehe

spelinng wrote:

plus one more P for the first letter hehehe

My point exactly, DA (and I don't mean district attorney). He also will not be practicing in Kengslan or Sante Merrys.

LDodd A.K.A. Friend of Jamie's:

The language you use (e.g. DA) speaks of the kind of person (or animal) you are and your posts smacks of racism :)

aha wrote:

LDodd A.K.A. Friend of Jamie's:
The language you use (e.g. DA) speaks of the kind of person (or animal) you are and your posts smacks of racism :)

Yes I was a friend of Jamie's. Oh, and I thought that minorities could not be racist. I am not the animal in this case. That is plain to see.

Please do not turn this into a racial case...Dr.Chua does not need that, I was at his bail hearing, thier was every race, sex and religon there. Please do not make the mistake of isolating him from anyone that may be here to help him. I know many white and black folks who have donated to his family since his arrest..And when he is free and tries to rebuild his pratice he will need all of us to come back..Dr.Chua didnt segragate and you shouldnt either.

Big Mistake wrote:

Please do not turn this into a racial case...Dr.Chua does not need that, I was at his bail hearing, thier was every race, sex and religon there. Please do not make the mistake of isolating him from anyone that may be here to help him. I know many white and black folks who have donated to his family since his arrest..And when he is free and tries to rebuild his pratice he will need all of us to come back..Dr.Chua didnt segragate and you shouldnt either.

I am not segregating or being racist. That is my point. My feelings concernning Dr. Chua have nothing to do with race. Furthermore, my best friend is Filipino.

this case is not about race and arguing the case here accomplishes NOTHING. Let the system work and pray for justice to prevail no matter who's "side" your on. demonizing either side of the case is irrational and childish.

LDodd wrote:

<quoted text>
I am not segregating or being racist. That is my point. My feelings concernning Dr. Chua have nothing to do with race. Furthermore, my best friend is Filipino.

A best friend is someone you don't make fun of

to all the american public opinions:please kindly think how long a doctor studies and educated in their lives,it takes time,patience,coolness,money,l ong hours of studying,getting educated,practical practicing,long hours in hands on experience,many years of practice to becomming a doctor in the medical profession and medical knowleicedge and what they sacretifice separations from their loved ones and families and friends and they give much of their freedoms towards helping people to get well again after illnessness and their health is also scificed to cure others>How can the american public accuse a doctor of murder when they take an oath to cure the sick and needy.Lets give this doctor Noel Chua MD a chance to prove his innocence and not be slendered by others that donot even know him in their lives.What has happened to the american legal systems saying- A person is innocent until they are proven gulity or not.Lets the american people and the general public give this doctor a chance to defend himself totally as a doctor and a medical professional and as a person.

If anyone has had a positive experience with Dr. Chua as their physician, it was just good luck. If you've ever been a patient, then you know he rarely, if ever, did a physical examination or touched anyone. A few simple blood tests ordered by Dr. Chua could have possibly saved my mom's life. Being kind and mild-mannered does not make a person a good doctor. Are people really stupid enough to believe this?? The only thing Dr. Chua was good at was perscribing weight loss drugs. He didn't care about anything else aside from having skinny patients. Please, all you Dr. Chua supporters, spare me.

Dr. Kavorkian probably took the "oath" as well. If Dr. Chua spent so much time in school studying, then he should have known not to perscribe all the drugs that he did for one individual. I'm not a Dr. and I know that mixing many meds can be fatal.

Let us all wait for the trial. I have a strong faith that Dr. Chua will be acquitted. As a person working with different doctors I wish I have work with Dr. Chua. Though, I met him only few times through my nephew who was also a doctor and a very dear friend of Dr. Chua I felt that kindness and compassion he showed to all his patients. That kind of kindness and compassion is hard to find in many doctors nowadays. I wish him the best and condolence to the family of Jamie.