2008 American Idol

Based on what you saw last night. Who will be kicked off tonight Th???? Who do u think will win in the end?????????

I think Brooke will get kicked off, that is the second time that she stopped and started a song, as far as the winner, I believe it is between Carlee or David Cook, both exceptional singers.

jason or brooke is going tonight. i think david cook or archuletta will win

AngS wrote:

jason or brooke is going tonight. i think david cook or archuletta will win

I agree with you.

Tonight will tell

ok the popularity contest needs to end and the singing competition begin. Syesha and Carly should not have been in the bottom 2, and Carly sure should not have went home. It should have been Jason.

Well seeing I just watched it I would say Carly is going.

Carly did not deserve to go! Brooke is the one who should go! How many times is she going to screw a song up before people realize that "hey, she might not be idol material"??

melancholy wrote:

Carly did not deserve to go! Brooke is the one who should go! How many times is she going to screw a song up before people realize that "hey, she might not be idol material"??

Maybe Brookes family were the ones that called in so many times....

Brook or unfortunately Jason should have gone for sure....but like Randy said, obviously as usual it is a popularity contest.I almost croaked when Brook said *I have never done this before* It was only a few weeks ago in back of the piano, she did the same thing!!!I love her to death, but she is NOT in the same league as the others....and as far as Carly, ya she rocks ,but I feel that she already had her chance...she was not an amature...she had records out before...give the true amatures a chance first.

yeah i am so mad jason is still in there. it's is almost the same perforance from him every week. he sounds like he is singing someone to sleep. ZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

AngS wrote:

yeah i am so mad jason is still in there. it's is almost the same perforance from him every week. he sounds like he is singing someone to sleep. ZZZZZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

Amen to that! He is cute as a button, but a performer, he isn't!

I'm pretty shocked myself. Brooke, Jason or Cyesha(sp?) should be the ones on their way out. But like someone said earlier....Carly's song choice could have got her voted off. I know as a Christian myself....the song that she sang came from a blasphemous musical that depicted Jesus as a sinner just like the rest of the world. I, personally didn't appreciate that. But putting that aside.....vocally, she didn't deserve to go yet. I still believe it will come down to the two Davids and I hope David Archuletta takes the whole thing.

Yup that song did her in for sure. And if it is between the 2 Davids, I think David A will get more votes. He appeals to young girls as well as the older audience. I think my grandma probably like him best. He is very sweet. Both of them will get deals. So they will just be competing for the title.

AngS, would I happen to know you pretty good? I think I have a hunch as to who you are. Should I know from your Topix name AngS? Just wondering because I think I know who you are. LOL Have I not also seen your husband posting on Topix too?

I don't know about you guys, but David C. gave me chills when he sang "Music of the Night". WOW!

Bible Believer wrote:

AngS, would I happen to know you pretty good? I think I have a hunch as to who you are. Should I know from your Topix name AngS? Just wondering because I think I know who you are. LOL Have I not also seen your husband posting on Topix too?

yep you should and you do! he has commented around.

sorry...that post to BB was from me...shared comp lol

melancholy wrote:

I don't know about you guys, but David C. gave me chills when he sang "Music of the Night". WOW!

i just kinda felt bad for him. i like him a lot but he was out of his element. very talented tho. kinda wondering about next week with neil diamond songs. the themes suck this year. mariah week was ok.

okay so tonight was not my favorite...Neil Diamond? Ugh! so here is who i thought did best in order..David A., Syesha, David C., Brooke, Jason...